Thomas Aquinas
Dominican friar whose synthesis of Aristotle and Christian theology became the most influential system of medieval philosophy.
Life
Thomas was born into a noble family near Aquino in southern Italy. Against his family's wishes he joined the new Dominican order in 1244 and studied under Albert the Great in Paris and Cologne. He taught at the University of Paris in two periods and at Dominican houses in Italy.
He wrote at great speed, dictating to several secretaries. In December 1273 he abruptly stopped writing, leaving the Summa Theologiae unfinished, and he died a few months later. Some of his positions were included in a condemnation at Paris in 1277; he was canonised in 1323.
Core ideas
- Faith and reason cannot conflict, since both come from God; some truths about God can be proved by reason, others are known only by revelation.
- The The Five Ways: five arguments for God's existence starting from features of the world.
- In creatures, essence and existence are distinct; in God alone they are identical.
- Natural law: moral principles are knowable by reason from human nature, beginning with “good is to be done and evil avoided”.
- We speak of God by analogy, neither in exactly the same sense as of creatures nor in a wholly different one.
In more depth
Reason and faith. Aquinas holds that reason and revelation cannot truly conflict, since both come from God. Some truths about God can be demonstrated by reason, such as that he exists and is one. Others, such as the Trinity, exceed reason and are known only by revelation, though reason can show they are not absurd. Philosophy is therefore a science in its own right, and theology uses it.
Essence and existence. In everything other than God, what a thing is differs from the fact that it is. One can understand what a phoenix is without knowing whether any exists. A thing's essence is related to its act of existing as potentiality to actuality, and so it must receive existence from another. In God alone essence and existence are identical. This is the centre of his metaphysics and is his own development, drawing on Ibn Sina.
The Five Ways. Each argument begins from an observed feature of the world: change, efficient causation, the contingency of things, degrees of perfection, and the directedness of things that lack knowledge. Each concludes to a first source. The first three are often misread as claiming that the world had a beginning in time. Aquinas denied that this could be proved. His point concerns an order of dependence and not an order of time, a series that cannot go back without end because the later members have no power of their own.
Speaking of God. Words such as good are used of God neither in the same sense as of creatures nor in a wholly different one. They are used analogically: goodness is truly in God, as its source, but in a way that exceeds our understanding. This steers between Maimonides' negative theology and treating God as one more being.
The human being. Following Aristotle, the soul is the form of the body, so a person is one substance, not a soul using a body. Because intellect has an operation that is not the act of any bodily organ, the soul can exist after death, but in an incomplete state. All our knowledge begins from the senses.
Natural law. Law is an ordinance of reason for the common good. The natural law is the rational creature's share in God's eternal law, and its first precept is that good is to be done and evil avoided. Its content follows the natural inclinations: to preserve life, to raise children, to know the truth and to live in society. A human law contrary to it is a corruption of law.
How an article works. The Summa Theologiae is built from thousands of articles in one form. A question is posed, such as whether God exists. Objections are listed first, as strong as they can be made. Then a text is quoted on the other side. Then Aquinas gives his own answer, and then replies to each objection in turn. The form comes from the classroom disputation. It obliges the author to state the opposing case before answering, and a reader should always read the objections.
Analogy at work. When we say that God is good and that Socrates is good, the word is not used in exactly the same sense, since goodness in God is identical with his being, nor in wholly different senses, or we would know nothing of God. It is used analogically, as “healthy” is said of an animal, of its diet and of its complexion. Goodness belongs first and fully to God and to creatures by sharing in it, though we learn the word from creatures.
The principle of double effect. Asking whether it is lawful to kill in self-defence, Aquinas notes that one act can have two effects, of which only one is intended. Defending one's life is intended and good; the attacker's death may follow beside the intention. The act is lawful if the force used is proportionate. Later moralists drew from this passage a general principle that distinguishes what one intends from what one foresees, still central to medical and military ethics.
Law. Aquinas defines law as an ordinance of reason for the common good, made by one who has care of the community, and promulgated. There are four kinds: the eternal law by which God governs creation; the natural law, which is the rational creature's share in it; human law, which applies natural law to particular conditions; and divine law, revealed in Scripture. A human law at odds with natural law is a corruption of law, a claim Martin Luther King cited in his Letter from Birmingham Jail.
The end of the work. In December 1273 Aquinas stopped writing, leaving the Summa unfinished, and is reported to have said that all he had written seemed like straw compared with what he had seen. He died a few months later. Some of his positions were among those condemned at Paris in 1277. He was canonised in 1323, and in 1879 Pope Leo XIII commended his philosophy as the model for Catholic teaching.
Works
- On Being and Essence, c. 1252–1256
- Summa contra Gentiles, c. 1259–1265
- Summa Theologiae, 1265–1273 (unfinished)
- Commentaries on Aristotle, c. 1267–1273
A common misreading
Aquinas is sometimes said to have simply “baptised” Aristotle. He disagreed with Aristotle on important points, including the eternity of the world, and drew heavily on Augustine and Neoplatonic sources.
Influenced by
Aristotle, Augustine of Hippo, Ibn Sina (Avicenna), Ibn Rushd (Averroes), Moses Maimonides, Boethius
Influenced
John Duns Scotus, William of Ockham, John Locke, G.E.M. Anscombe
Related ideas
The Five Ways, The doctrine of double effect
Schools and eras
Scholasticism, Aristotelianism, Medieval
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Thomas Aquinas in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.