Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

William of Ockham

c. 1287 CE – 1347 CE · Surrey, England; Oxford; Avignon; Munich · European

Franciscan logician and nominalist, remembered for the principle of parsimony known as Ockham's razor.

Also known as: Occam

Life

Ockham was born in the village of Ockham in Surrey and studied theology at Oxford. In 1324 he was summoned to the papal court at Avignon to answer charges that his teaching was heretical. While there he became involved in the Franciscan dispute with Pope John XXII over apostolic poverty.

In 1328 he fled Avignon and took refuge with the emperor Louis of Bavaria. He was excommunicated and spent the rest of his life in Munich writing on politics and the limits of papal power.

Core ideas

In more depth

Only individuals. Ockham denies that there is anything universal outside the mind. Everything that exists is singular. A universal is a mental sign, a concept that naturally signifies many individuals, as smoke signifies fire. In his mature view the concept is simply the act of understanding itself. Scotus' common natures and formal distinctions are rejected as unintelligible.

The razor. He repeatedly applies the rule that plurality is not to be posited without necessity. In practice this means admitting an entity only on the strength of self-evidence, experience or the authority of Scripture. Using it, he reduces Aristotle's ten categories to substances and qualities: motion, time, place, relation and quantity are not additional things but ways of speaking about substances and qualities.

Mental language. Thought itself has the structure of a language, with terms and propositions, of which spoken languages are conventional signs. Many philosophical confusions arise from assuming that every noun names a thing. Careful analysis of what terms stand for in different contexts, the theory of supposition, shows that sentences containing abstract nouns can be restated without them.

Knowledge. We have intuitive cognition of individual things, by which we know that they exist and have certain qualities. God could, by his absolute power, cause such a cognition without the object, a possibility that later thinkers saw as an opening to scepticism.

God, morality and politics. God's omnipotence means he can do anything that involves no contradiction. Moral obligation rests on divine command, though right reason also has a place in his ethics. In his political writings, produced in exile, Ockham argued that a pope who falls into heresy can be judged and deposed, and defended the independence of secular rule and the natural rights of individuals and communities.

Supposition. Ockham's logic turns on what a term stands for in a sentence. In “a man is running” the term stands for individual men: this is personal supposition. In “man is a species” it stands for a concept in the mind. In “man is a three-letter word” it stands for itself. Many philosophical errors, he argues, come from confusing these. The sentence about species tempts us to posit a thing called humanity, when the term there stands only for a concept.

How a concept can be general. If only individuals exist, what makes the concept “man” apply to all men? Ockham first held that a universal is a mental picture with a merely thought-of existence. He later gave this up as an unnecessary posit and held that the concept simply is the act of thinking, an act that is a natural sign of many individuals, as smoke is of fire. Spoken words are conventional signs tied to these natural ones.

What God could do. Ockham makes constant use of the principle that God can do anything that involves no contradiction, and can produce directly whatever he normally produces through created causes. So any two really distinct things can exist apart. This is a test for what is truly distinct, and it also loosens the tie between how the world is and how it must be. He even grants that God could cause us to seem to see a star that does not exist.

The break with the pope. Summoned to Avignon in 1324 to answer for his theology, Ockham was drawn into the Franciscan dispute over whether Christ and the apostles owned anything. Concluding that Pope John XXII had fallen into heresy, he fled in 1328 to the court of Emperor Ludwig of Bavaria and wrote on politics for the rest of his life. He distinguished a right of use from ownership and argued for limits on papal power in both spiritual and temporal matters.

Works

A common misreading

The wording usually quoted as the razor, “entities are not to be multiplied beyond necessity”, does not appear in Ockham's writings. It was formulated by later authors.

Influenced by

Aristotle, John Duns Scotus, Peter Abelard

Influenced

Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, George Berkeley

Related ideas

Ockham's razor

Schools and eras

Scholasticism, Medieval

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open William of Ockham in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.