Boethius
Roman senator who translated Aristotle's logic into Latin and wrote the Consolation of Philosophy while awaiting execution.
Life
Boethius was born into an aristocratic Roman family shortly after the end of the western empire and rose to high office under the Ostrogothic king Theodoric. He planned to translate all of Plato and Aristotle into Latin and completed part of Aristotle's logic, with commentaries.
Around 523 he was accused of treason, imprisoned at Pavia and later executed. In prison he wrote the Consolation of Philosophy, in which Philosophy, personified as a woman, visits him in his cell. It became one of the most read books of the Middle Ages.
Core ideas
- True happiness cannot lie in gifts of fortune such as wealth, power or fame, which can be lost.
- God's foreknowledge does not remove freedom, because God sees all time in a single eternal present.
- Eternity is “the complete possession all at once of unending life” (Consolation V.6).
- His commentary on Porphyry posed the Problem of universals for the Latin Middle Ages.
In more depth
The setting. The Consolation of Philosophy was written in prison by a man awaiting execution. Philosophy appears as a woman and treats the prisoner like a patient, beginning with mild remedies and moving to stronger ones. The work alternates prose and verse and, although its author was a Christian, argues from reason alone.
Fortune and happiness. Fortune's nature is to change, so anyone who trusts her gifts has no cause to complain when she takes them back. Wealth, office, fame and pleasure are partial and insecure goods. People pursue them because they are really seeking one thing, complete happiness, which must be unified and incapable of being lost. Philosophy argues that this can only be the highest good, and that the highest good is God.
Why the wicked seem to prosper. All people aim at the good, the good attain it and the wicked do not, so the wicked are in fact powerless and are punished by being what they are. Providence is the plan of things in the divine mind; fate is the same plan unfolded in time. What looks like disorder is order seen from too close.
Foreknowledge and freedom. If God foreknows everything, it seems that nothing can happen otherwise, and praise and blame lose their point. Boethius' solution rests on the claim that knowledge depends on the knower's nature. God is eternal, and eternity is the complete possession all at once of unending life. God does not foresee the future; he sees all of time in a single present. Seeing someone walk does not make them walk of necessity. Events are necessary only on the condition that they are known, not in themselves.
Legacy. His definition of eternity and his distinction between two kinds of necessity became standard in medieval thought. His translations of Aristotle's logic were almost the only Aristotle available in the Latin West for centuries, and a remark in one of his commentaries set off the medieval debate about universals.
The man and his fall. Boethius came from the highest Roman aristocracy and served the Ostrogothic king Theoderic as consul and then as head of the civil service. Around 523 he was accused of treason for defending a senator charged with corresponding with the eastern emperor, imprisoned at Pavia and executed, at some point between 524 and 526. He had planned to translate all of Plato and Aristotle into Latin and to show their agreement. He completed only the logical works of Aristotle.
Philosophy's diagnosis. Lady Philosophy appears in his cell, drives away the Muses of poetry who have been feeding his grief, and examines him like a physician. His illness is that he has forgotten what he is. The cure proceeds in stages, gentle remedies first. Fortune has not changed toward him: change is her nature, and whoever climbs on her wheel must accept the descent. Wealth, office, fame and pleasure are then shown to be fragments of a good that exists whole only in God.
Eternity defined. To solve the problem of foreknowledge Boethius gives a definition that became standard: eternity is the complete, simultaneous and perfect possession of unbounded life. God does not foresee the future from a point in time; he sees all times in a single present, as one watching from a height sees the whole road at once. Seeing a man walk does not make him walk. And something may be necessary given that it is known without being necessary in itself.
The theological tractates and “person”. Boethius also wrote short works applying Aristotelian logic to the Trinity and the nature of Christ. In one he defines a person as an individual substance of a rational nature, a formula used throughout the Middle Ages. Another asks how things can be good by existing without being identical to the Good. These tractates, more than the Consolation, gave the scholastics their model of theology done with the tools of logic.
Works
- Translations of and commentaries on Aristotle's logic, c. 510–522
- Theological treatises (Opuscula sacra), c. 512–522
- The Consolation of Philosophy, c. 524
A common misreading
Readers often expect the Consolation to be a Christian book. Although Boethius was a Christian and wrote on theology, it never mentions Christ or Scripture and argues from philosophy alone.
Influenced by
Plato, Aristotle, Plotinus, Augustine of Hippo
Influenced
Anselm of Canterbury, Peter Abelard, Thomas Aquinas
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Boethius in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.