Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Ibn Rushd (Averroes)

1126 CE – 1198 CE · Córdoba, Spain; Marrakesh, Morocco · Islamic

Andalusian judge and physician whose commentaries on Aristotle earned him the title “the Commentator” in medieval Europe.

Also known as: Averroes, Abu al-Walid Muhammad ibn Rushd, the Commentator

Life

Ibn Rushd was born into a family of prominent jurists in Córdoba. He served as a judge in Seville and Córdoba and as court physician to the Almohad caliph, who is said to have asked him to explain Aristotle. He wrote short, middle and long commentaries on almost all of Aristotle's works.

In 1195 he fell from favour, his books were ordered burned, and he was briefly banished. He was restored shortly before his death in Marrakesh. His influence was far greater among Jewish and Latin Christian readers than in the Islamic world.

Core ideas

In more depth

The Commentator. Ibn Rushd wrote short, middle and long commentaries on almost all of Aristotle, aiming to recover Aristotle's own teaching from what he regarded as the distortions of Ibn Sina. In Latin Europe he was known simply as the Commentator.

Philosophy and the Law. The Decisive Treatise is a legal opinion on whether the study of philosophy is permitted. It argues that the Law commands reflection on creation, that demonstration is the most perfect form of reflection, and that philosophy is therefore obligatory for those capable of it. Truth does not contradict truth. Where demonstration and the apparent sense of Scripture conflict, Scripture must be interpreted, but such interpretations should not be disclosed to those who cannot follow them.

Three kinds of assent. People differ in how they are convinced: some by demonstration, some by dialectical argument, most by rhetoric and images. Scripture addresses all three. The so-called doctrine of double truth, that something can be true in philosophy and false in religion, was attributed to his Latin followers; it is not his view.

Reply to al-Ghazali. The Incoherence of the Incoherence answers the earlier work point by point. To deny that things have causal natures is to deny that they have natures at all, and so to make knowledge impossible, since to know a thing is to know its causes. On the eternity of the world he argues that the dispute between philosophers and theologians is largely verbal.

The intellect. In the Long Commentary on De Anima he concludes that the material intellect, the capacity to receive concepts, is a single separate substance shared by all human beings. Individuals think by being joined to it through their images. This appeared to deny personal immortality and was fiercely opposed by Aquinas.

Afterlife of the work. His influence in the Islamic world was limited. In Hebrew and Latin translation he shaped Jewish and Christian philosophy for three centuries.

The commission. Ibn Rushd was a judge and physician in Almohad Spain. According to a contemporary report, the philosopher Ibn Tufayl presented him to the caliph Abu Ya'qub Yusuf, who asked what the philosophers held about whether the heavens are eternal, and then complained of the obscurity of Aristotle's books. Ibn Rushd took on the task of explaining them. He regarded Aristotle as the model that nature produced to show the highest human perfection.

The three issues answered. Al-Ghazali had charged the philosophers with unbelief on three points. On the eternity of the world, Ibn Rushd replies that the dispute is nearly verbal: all agree that the world depends on God. On God's knowledge of particulars, he replies that God's knowledge is neither universal nor particular in our sense, since ours is caused by things and his is their cause. On resurrection, he affirms it and says only that the manner is open to interpretation.

Against Ibn Sina. Much of Ibn Rushd's criticism is aimed at Ibn Sina, whom he blames for exposing philosophy to attack. He rejects the scheme of emanation, on which only one thing can come from the One. He rejects the distinction that makes existence something added to essence. And he holds that the proper proof of God is Aristotle's argument from motion in physics, not a metaphysical argument from possible and necessary being.

Disgrace and survival. In 1195, under political pressure, he was tried, his teachings were condemned, and he was banished to Lucena; he died in Marrakesh in 1198. His writings survived chiefly in Hebrew and Latin translations. In thirteenth-century Paris, masters who followed his reading of Aristotle were called Averroists, and their views were among the targets of the condemnations of 1270 and 1277. His book on jurisprudence remained in use in Islamic legal education.

Works

A common misreading

Averroes did not teach “double truth”, the idea that something can be true in philosophy and false in religion. That position was attributed to some of his Latin followers; he held that truth is one.

Influenced by

Aristotle, al-Farabi, Ibn Sina (Avicenna), al-Ghazali

Influenced

Moses Maimonides, Thomas Aquinas

Schools and eras

Falsafa, Aristotelianism, Islamic Golden Age

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Ibn Rushd (Averroes) in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.