Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

The doctrine of double effect

The principle that it may be permissible to cause a harm as a foreseen side effect that it would be wrong to cause as a means or an end.

Explanation

The idea comes from Thomas Aquinas's discussion of killing in self-defence: one act may have two effects, only one of which is intended. As later stated, the doctrine allows an act with a bad effect when the act itself is not wrong, the bad effect is not intended, the good is not achieved by means of the bad, and the good is enough to outweigh the bad.

Standard applications: a doctor may give a dying patient enough morphine to relieve pain, foreseeing that it will shorten life, but may not give it in order to kill. A bomber may destroy a munitions factory, foreseeing civilian deaths, but may not bomb civilians to break morale. In the trolley cases, it is offered to explain why one may divert the tram but not push the man.

Critics

Consequentialists reply that what matters is the outcome, which is the same either way. Others doubt that the line between what is intended and what is merely foreseen can be drawn firmly. Philippa Foot proposed that the cases are better explained by the difference between doing and allowing.

Jeremy Bentham, Philippa Foot

Where scholars disagree

The doctrine is written into much medical ethics and the law of war, and its foundations remain contested.

Originator

Thomas Aquinas

Related ideas

Deontology, Consequentialism

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open The doctrine of double effect in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.