Aristotle
Plato's student and the founder of formal logic, whose treatises shaped inquiry in almost every field for two thousand years.
Life
Aristotle was born in 384 BCE in Stagira, in northern Greece. His father, Nicomachus, was physician to the Macedonian king. At about seventeen he went to Athens and joined Plato's Academy, where he stayed for roughly twenty years, until Plato's death.
He then left Athens, spending time at Assos in Asia Minor and on the island of Lesbos, where he carried out much of his biological research. Around 343 BCE Philip II of Macedon invited him to tutor his son, the future Alexander the Great. In 335 BCE he returned to Athens and taught at the Lyceum, where his school came to be known as the Peripatetic school.
After Alexander's death in 323 BCE, anti-Macedonian feeling in Athens led him to withdraw to Chalcis on Euboea, where he died the following year. The works he published in his lifetime are lost. What survives is a body of treatises that appear to be working notes or lecture texts, arranged by later editors.
Core ideas
- Logic: the first systematic theory of valid inference, the syllogistic (Prior Analytics).
- Substance and hylomorphism: individual things are compounds of matter and form. Forms do not exist apart from the things that have them.
- The Four causes: a full explanation states a thing's matter, form, source of change and end.
- Ethics aims at Eudaimonia, a flourishing life of activity in accordance with virtue.
- Virtues of character are settled dispositions acquired by practice, each lying between an excess and a deficiency (the Doctrine of the mean).
- Human beings are by nature political animals, and the city exists for the sake of living well (Politics, Book I).
In more depth
Substance. Aristotle asks what is real in the primary sense. In the Categories it is the individual thing, this man or this horse; qualities, quantities and the rest exist only as belonging to such things. Against Plato, he denies that forms exist apart from the things that have them. In the Metaphysics the question is pressed further: is a thing's substance its matter, its form, or the compound? He argues that form, what it is to be that kind of thing, has the best claim.
Matter, form and change. Parmenides had made change look impossible. Aristotle answers that in every change something persists and something is gained or lost: the bronze persists and acquires the shape of a statue. What changes is potentially what it becomes, and change is the actualising of that potential. To understand anything fully is to know its four causes: what it is made of, what it is, what brought it about, and what it is for.
Purpose in nature. Living things develop toward a mature form. An acorn becomes an oak unless prevented. Aristotle regards this directedness as a real feature of nature that needs no designer. The soul is the form of a living body, the set of capacities that make it alive, and so it is not a separate thing that could leave the body, with the possible exception of intellect, about which his remarks are brief and obscure.
Logic and science. Aristotle created formal logic. The syllogistic identifies which arguments with two premises are valid in virtue of their form alone. A science, on his model, demonstrates its truths from first principles that are grasped by intellect after long experience. He also formulated the principle of non-contradiction and argued that it cannot be proved, though anyone who denies it can be shown to rely on it.
Ethics and politics. The human good is eudaimonia, flourishing, which consists in activity of the soul in accordance with virtue over a complete life. Virtues of character are settled dispositions formed by habit; each lies in a mean between excess and deficiency, fixed by the judgement of a person of practical wisdom. Humans are by nature political animals, and the city exists for the sake of living well. The best life of all, he argues at the end of the Ethics, is contemplation.
Objections. His physics and cosmology were overturned in the seventeenth century, and with them the appeal to final causes outside biology. His defences of natural slavery and of the subordination of women are rejected. The ethics, by contrast, is the main source of modern virtue ethics, and his logic was the standard account until the nineteenth century.
A worked example of the four causes. Take a bronze statue. Its matter is the bronze. Its form is the shape that makes it a statue of this figure. Its moving cause is the sculptor, or more exactly the art of sculpture in him. Its end is what it is for. In natural things, Aristotle holds, form, mover and end often coincide: the form of an oak is what the acorn grows toward, and it was passed on by a parent oak that already had it. To explain a thing fully is to answer all four questions.
The soul. On the Soul defines the soul as the form of a living body: what makes a body with organs actually alive. It is not a separate thing lodged in the body, any more than the shape of a seal is separate from the wax. Plants have a soul for nutrition and growth, animals add perception and movement, humans add thought. Only the intellect raises a difficulty, since thinking seems to have no bodily organ. A short and obscure chapter on an intellect that “makes all things” occupied commentators for two thousand years.
Practical wisdom. Virtue of character is a settled disposition to feel and act in a mean between excess and deficiency: courage between rashness and cowardice, generosity between waste and meanness. The mean is not a midpoint to be calculated. It is what a person of practical wisdom would choose in the particular case, and practical wisdom is acquired by experience and good upbringing. This is why Aristotle says ethics cannot be as exact as mathematics, and why the young make poor students of it.
The unmoved mover. Metaphysics XII argues that eternal motion requires a cause that moves without being moved. Such a cause can have no matter and no unrealised potential. It moves the heavens as an object of desire moves a lover, by being what they strive toward. Its only activity is thought, and its only worthy object is itself: thought thinking itself. Medieval Jewish, Christian and Muslim philosophers identified this being with God, though Aristotle's god neither creates the world nor knows its details.
Works
- Categories and Prior Analytics (parts of the Organon), c. 350 BCE
- Physics, c. 350 BCE
- Metaphysics, c. 350–322 BCE
- On the Soul (De Anima), c. 350 BCE
- Nicomachean Ethics, c. 340–322 BCE
- Politics, c. 335–322 BCE
- Poetics, c. 335 BCE
The treatises were revised over many years and cannot be dated individually with confidence. The titles and arrangement are largely the work of later editors.
Where scholars disagree
Interpreters disagree about whether the Nicomachean Ethics identifies the best life with contemplation alone (Book X) or with a wider life of virtuous activity (Book I).
A common misreading
The line "We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit" is widely attributed to Aristotle. It is Will Durant's summary of Aristotle's view in The Story of Philosophy (1926), not a sentence from Aristotle.
Influenced by
Influenced
Ibn Sina (Avicenna), Ibn Rushd (Averroes), Thomas Aquinas, al-Farabi
Related ideas
Four causes, Doctrine of the mean, Eudaimonia, Theory of Forms, Moral responsibility, Virtue ethics, Causation
Schools and eras
Aristotelianism, Classical Greek
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Aristotle in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.