Moses Maimonides
The foremost medieval Jewish philosopher, who sought to reconcile the Hebrew Bible with Aristotelian science.
Life
Maimonides was born in Córdoba. When the Almohad dynasty ended toleration of Jews in Muslim Spain, his family left, living for a time in Fez before settling in Egypt. There he became head of the Jewish community and a court physician.
He wrote in Hebrew and in Arabic. The Mishneh Torah is a comprehensive code of Jewish law. The Guide of the Perplexed, written in Arabic in Hebrew letters, addresses readers troubled by conflicts between Scripture and philosophy.
Core ideas
- Biblical language describing God in bodily or human terms must be read figuratively.
- Negative theology: we can say only what God is not; positive attributes would compromise God's unity.
- The creation of the world cannot be demonstrated, but neither can its eternity, and creation is the more reasonable belief.
- The highest human perfection is intellectual knowledge of God, which issues in righteous action.
In more depth
The perplexed reader. The Guide is addressed to someone who is faithful to the Law and also trained in philosophy, and who is troubled because Scripture read literally contradicts what reason demonstrates. Maimonides' remedy is interpretation: when the plain sense of a text is impossible, it must be read figuratively.
God without attributes. The first target is every bodily description of God. But Maimonides goes further and denies that God has attributes at all, since any attribute distinct from God's essence would introduce plurality into what is absolutely one. Words such as living, powerful and wise are said of God and of creatures in wholly different senses. Statements about God are therefore either about his actions or are negations. To say God is powerful is to deny that he is weak. Knowledge of God advances by knowing more of what he is not.
Creation or eternity. Aristotle held the world to be eternal; the Law teaches that it was created. Maimonides argues that neither position has been demonstrated, and that Aristotle's arguments are only probable. Since the question is open, he follows creation, which also makes room for miracle and revelation. Readers have long disagreed about whether this was his real view.
Prophecy and the commandments. Prophecy is a natural perfection of the intellect and imagination together, which God can withhold. Every commandment has a reason: to teach true beliefs, to form character or to order society. Sacrifice, for example, was a concession to habits the people could not abandon at once.
The problem of reading him. Maimonides says in his introduction that he has written with deliberate contradictions to conceal some matters from unprepared readers. This has produced two traditions of interpretation, one taking him as a harmoniser of Law and philosophy, the other as a philosopher writing with caution.
The two great works. Maimonides, born in Córdoba and settled in Egypt, where he was physician at the court of Saladin's vizier, is the author of two works that seem to pull apart. The Mishneh Torah is a complete code of Jewish law in clear Hebrew, intended to make the law accessible without the labour of the Talmud. The Guide of the Perplexed, in Arabic, is deliberately difficult. He says he has scattered its teachings and included contradictions on purpose, so that only a prepared reader will follow.
The parable of the palace. Near the end of the Guide he describes a king in his palace. Some subjects are outside the city; some are in the city with their backs to the palace; some seek it and never see its walls; some walk around it looking for the gate; some enter the antechambers; a few are in the king's presence. Those who study only the law are walking around the walls. Those who have mastered natural science and metaphysics are inside. The passage ranks philosophical knowledge of God above legal observance alone, and caused lasting offence.
Ethics as a mean. In his legal writings Maimonides adopts Aristotle's doctrine that each virtue is a mean between extremes, and presents the commandments as a training in moderation. Someone whose character has gone to one extreme should go for a time to the opposite, as a bent stick is straightened. He makes exceptions: one should be very far from pride and from anger. The highest human perfection, however, is intellectual and not moral.
The controversy. After his death the Guide and parts of the code were attacked for subordinating tradition to philosophy, and in the 1230s his books were burned in France. Others made him the foundation of Jewish rationalism. Through a Latin translation the Guide was read by Aquinas, who cites “Rabbi Moses” on creation and on the divine attributes while rejecting the strictly negative account of what can be said of God.
Works
- Commentary on the Mishnah, 1168
- Mishneh Torah, c. 1180
- The Guide of the Perplexed, c. 1190
Where scholars disagree
Maimonides says the Guide deliberately conceals some of its teaching. Whether his true views were more radically Aristotelian than the surface of the text suggests is a long-running dispute.
A common misreading
His birth year is often given as 1135. That date comes from a later tradition; his own statement in a manuscript colophon points to 1138, which most scholars now accept.
Influenced by
Aristotle, al-Farabi, Ibn Sina (Avicenna)
Influenced
Thomas Aquinas, Baruch Spinoza, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
Schools and eras
Aristotelianism, Medieval, Islamic Golden Age
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Moses Maimonides in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.