Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Augustine of Hippo

354 CE – 430 CE · Thagaste and Hippo, Roman North Africa · European

North African bishop who fused Christianity with Platonism and shaped Western thinking about the will, time, evil and the self.

Also known as: St Augustine, Aurelius Augustinus

Life

Augustine was born in Thagaste, in present-day Algeria, to a pagan father and a Christian mother. He taught rhetoric in Carthage, Rome and Milan, and for about nine years followed Manichaeism, a religion of two warring cosmic principles. Reading “the books of the Platonists” and hearing the preaching of Ambrose in Milan led to his conversion to Christianity in 386.

He returned to Africa, was ordained, and from about 396 served as bishop of Hippo, where he wrote constantly against rival doctrines. He died in 430 while the city was under siege by the Vandals.

Core ideas

In more depth

Against the sceptics. Augustine had been tempted by Academic scepticism and answered it early. Even if I am mistaken about everything else, he argues, I cannot be mistaken that I exist, for one who does not exist cannot be mistaken. The same holds for knowing that I live and that I want to be happy. The argument anticipates Descartes, though Augustine uses it to show that some truths are secure, not to rebuild knowledge from one point.

Illumination. How does a changeable mind grasp unchanging truths, such as those of mathematics and of what is good? Not from the senses, and not from itself. Augustine's answer is that the mind sees them in a light supplied by God, as the eye sees bodies in sunlight. Truth is therefore found by turning inward and then upward. This adapts Plato's recollection without a previous life of the soul.

Evil as privation. As a young man Augustine had accepted the Manichaean view that evil is a substance at war with good. From the Platonists he learned to see evil as the lack of a good that ought to be present, as blindness is in an eye. Everything God made is good so far as it exists. Moral evil arises when a free will turns from the higher good to a lower one.

Will, sin and grace. Human beings have free choice, and that is why sin is blameworthy. But in his later writings against Pelagius, Augustine insists that since the Fall the will cannot choose rightly without grace, and that grace is given by God's choice and not earned. How this leaves room for freedom has been argued over ever since, by Catholics and Protestants alike.

Time. In Confessions XI he asks what time is. The past no longer exists, the future does not yet exist, and the present has no length. Yet we measure time. He concludes that it is measured in the mind, as a stretching of the soul: the present of things past is memory, of things present attention, and of things future expectation.

The two cities. The City of God, written after the sack of Rome, divides humanity by what it loves: love of God to the point of contempt for self, or love of self to the point of contempt for God. The two cities are intermingled until the end, and no earthly state can be identified with either. Political order secures an earthly peace that the pilgrim city uses without mistaking it for the final good.

The Confessions. The first nine books tell Augustine's life as a prayer addressed to God: the theft of pears done for the pleasure of doing wrong, the years as a Manichee, the influence of Ambrose in Milan, and the conversion in a garden, when he heard a child's voice say “take and read” and opened Paul's letters. “Our heart is restless until it rests in you” is the theme. The work invented a way of writing about the self as a story whose meaning is seen only in retrospect.

Memory. Book X asks how God can be sought and turns to memory, described as a vast hall holding images of things perceived, the truths of mathematics, and one's past feelings, which can be recalled without being felt again. I can remember joy while sad and even remember forgetting. The mind, he concludes, is too large to grasp itself. The discussion made the inward turn a method: the way to God passes through the examination of one's own mind.

Signs and teaching. In The Teacher Augustine argues that words alone teach nothing. A word is a sign, and a sign instructs only someone who already knows the thing it signifies. When a teacher explains, the learner consults the truth present within and judges whether what is said is so. That inner teacher is Christ. On Christian Doctrine builds a general theory of signs on this basis, which became the starting point of medieval thinking about language.

The will divided. Augustine describes, before his conversion, commanding himself to will and not obeying: the mind orders the body and is obeyed, orders itself and is resisted. The explanation is that the will is not whole; habit has become a kind of necessity. This analysis of a will at odds with itself has no real precedent in Greek philosophy, which explained wrongdoing by ignorance or by the pull of the non-rational parts of the soul. It lies behind his doctrine of grace.

Just war and the earthly city. Because no earthly state embodies true justice, Augustine expects only a limited peace from politics, an ordered agreement that both cities make use of. War may be waged to secure that peace, on a legitimate authority's command and with right intention. These remarks, scattered across letters and the City of God, were organised by later writers into just war theory.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Whether Augustine's late doctrine of grace leaves any real room for free will has been disputed since his own lifetime.

A common misreading

The prayer “give me chastity and continence, but not yet” is sometimes quoted as Augustine's considered attitude. In the Confessions (VIII.7) he reports it as the prayer of his youth, and condemns it.

Influenced by

Plato, Plotinus, Cicero

Influenced

Anselm of Canterbury, Thomas Aquinas, René Descartes, Blaise Pascal

Schools and eras

Neoplatonism, Medieval, Hellenistic and Roman

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Augustine of Hippo in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.