John Locke
English philosopher who traced all ideas to experience and founded political authority on natural rights and the consent of the governed.
Life
Locke studied and taught at Oxford, where he trained in medicine. In 1667 he joined the household of the future Earl of Shaftesbury as physician and adviser, which drew him into the politics of opposition to Charles II and James II. In 1683 he fled to the Dutch Republic.
He returned to England after the Revolution of 1688 and published, within about a year, the three works that made his name. The Two Treatises and the Letter Concerning Toleration appeared anonymously.
Core ideas
- There are no innate ideas; the mind begins as “white paper” (Tabula rasa) and all its materials come from sensation and reflection.
- Primary qualities such as shape and solidity are in bodies themselves; secondary qualities such as colour are powers to produce sensations in us.
- Personal identity consists in continuity of consciousness, not sameness of substance.
- People have natural rights to life, liberty and property, and government exists by consent to protect them.
- A government that betrays its trust may be resisted and replaced.
In more depth
No innate ideas. Book I of the Essay argues that there are no principles stamped on the mind at birth. Supposedly innate truths are not known to children or accepted by everyone, and universal agreement, if it existed, could be explained otherwise. The mind begins like white paper, and all its materials come from experience.
Ideas. Experience has two sources: sensation, which supplies ideas of external things, and reflection, which supplies ideas of the mind's own operations. Simple ideas are received passively. The mind then compounds, compares and abstracts to form complex ideas. Words stand for ideas, and general words for abstract ideas.
Qualities and substance. Primary qualities, such as solidity, extension, figure and motion, belong to bodies themselves, and our ideas of them resemble them. Secondary qualities, such as colour and taste, are powers in bodies to produce ideas in us and resemble nothing in the object. Of substance, the thing that has the qualities, we have only the idea of a something we know not what. We sort things by nominal essences, the ideas we attach to names, and do not know their real inner constitutions.
Personal identity. Being the same person over time consists in sameness of consciousness, as far back as memory reaches, and not in sameness of soul or body. Person is a forensic term, concerned with responsibility. Reid objected that memory presupposes identity and cannot constitute it.
Limits of knowledge. Knowledge is the perception of agreement or disagreement among ideas. We have it of our own existence, of God, and of what is present to the senses, but of nature at large we have only probable opinion.
Government. In the state of nature people are free and equal under a law of nature that forbids harming another in life, health, liberty or possessions. Property arises when a person mixes labour with what was common, provided enough and as good is left. The inconvenience of each being judge in their own case leads people to consent to government. Its power is a trust, and a government that breaks it may be resisted.
Toleration. The state exists to protect civil interests and has no competence over the care of souls, since belief cannot be compelled. He excluded atheists and Catholics, a limit later readers have criticised.
The Molyneux problem. William Molyneux put a question that Locke added to the Essay. A man born blind has learned by touch to tell a cube from a sphere. Suppose he is made to see: could he, by sight alone, say which is which? Locke and Molyneux answered no, since the connection between how a shape feels and how it looks must be learned from experience. The question, taken up by Berkeley and Diderot, became a test case for empiricism, and later for experimental study.
Words. Book III of the Essay holds that words stand for ideas in the mind of the speaker. General words stand for abstract ideas, which we make by leaving out what is particular. The kinds into which we sort things, such as gold or horse, have a nominal essence, the list of observable features we attach to the name, and a real essence, the unknown inner constitution from which the features flow. Since we sort by the first and do not know the second, the boundaries of species are the workmanship of the understanding.
Property. In the Second Treatise each person owns his own body and labour. By mixing labour with what nature provides in common, he makes it his: the acorns are mine when I gather them. Two limits apply in the state of nature. There must be enough and as good left for others, and no one may take more than he can use before it spoils. The invention of money, which does not spoil, allows unequal holdings by a tacit consent. Critics dispute whether the limits survive that step.
The right of resistance. Government is a trust. When a legislature or prince acts against the trust, by invading property or setting up arbitrary power, the people are released from obedience and may establish a new government. Who shall judge? The people shall. Locke answers the objection that this invites constant rebellion: people bear a great deal before they stir. The book was published after the revolution of 1688, though largely written earlier, and was a source for the American Declaration of Independence.
The man. Locke was a physician and adviser to the Earl of Shaftesbury, leader of the opposition to Charles II, and spent years in exile in Holland. He was involved in the administration of English colonies, including Carolina, where slavery was established, which sits badly with his arguments against absolute power.
Works
- A Letter Concerning Toleration, 1689
- Two Treatises of Government, 1689
- An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, 1689
- Some Thoughts Concerning Education, 1693
A common misreading
The Two Treatises were long read as a justification of the Revolution of 1688. Most scholars now hold that the bulk was written several years earlier, during the crisis of about 1679–1683.
Influenced by
René Descartes, Thomas Hobbes, Francis Bacon, William of Ockham
Influenced
George Berkeley, David Hume, Voltaire, Montesquieu, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Immanuel Kant
Related ideas
Tabula rasa, Personal identity
Schools and eras
Empiricism, Early Modern, Enlightenment
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open John Locke in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.