Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

William James

1842 CE – 1910 CE · New York and Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA · North American

American psychologist and philosopher who made pragmatism famous and defended the right to believe beyond the evidence in certain cases.

Life

James was born into a wealthy and intellectual New York family; the novelist Henry James was his brother. He took a medical degree at Harvard, suffered a long period of depression in his twenties, and taught at Harvard from 1873, moving from physiology to psychology to philosophy.

His Principles of Psychology established him as a founder of the discipline in America. His later lectures, written for general audiences, made him the best-known American philosopher of his time.

Core ideas

In more depth

Pragmatism as method. James presents pragmatism first as a way of settling metaphysical disputes that might otherwise be endless. Ask what practical difference it would make if one side or the other were true. If none, the dispute is idle. He credits the principle to Peirce.

Truth. An idea is true if it works: if it leads us prosperously from one part of experience to another, can be assimilated, validated and verified. The true is only the expedient in the way of our thinking, in the long run and on the whole. Truth happens to an idea; it is made true by events. Critics, Russell among them, replied that a belief can be useful and false. James protested that he never denied that true ideas must agree with reality; he was saying what that agreement amounts to.

The will to believe. When an option is living, forced and momentous, and cannot be decided on intellectual grounds, our passional nature not only may but must decide. To refuse to choose is itself a choice, with its own risk of losing the truth. Religious belief is such a case. In some matters, such as trust between people, faith in a fact can help to create the fact.

The stream of thought. In the Principles of Psychology consciousness is described as a stream, continuous and always changing, with a fringe of relations around each focus. It is not a chain of separate ideas. He treats the self, habit, attention and emotion in ways that shaped later psychology.

Radical empiricism. Relations between things are as much matters of direct experience as the things. The world is made of one kind of stuff, pure experience, which counts as mental or physical according to the relations it enters.

Religion and pluralism. The Varieties studies religious experience through first-hand reports and judges it by its fruits for life. He held that the universe is unfinished, a pluralism in which human effort makes a real difference.

The squirrel. James introduces pragmatism with a camping dispute. A man walks round a tree; a squirrel on the trunk keeps moving so that the tree is always between them. Does the man go round the squirrel? It depends, James says, on what you practically mean. If you mean passing from north of him to east, south and west, yes. If you mean being in front of him, then to his right, behind and to his left, no. Make the distinction and there is no occasion for further dispute.

The crisis of 1870. As a young man James fell into a depression bound up with the fear that the will is not free. Reading the French philosopher Renouvier, he recorded in his diary a resolution: my first act of free will shall be to believe in free will. The episode shaped his later doctrine that some beliefs help to make themselves true. A climber who must leap a chasm is more likely to succeed if he believes he can.

Emotion. With the Danish physiologist Lange, James proposed that an emotion is the feeling of bodily changes as they occur. Common sense says we lose our fortune, are sorry and weep. The correct order is that we weep and feel sorry because we weep; we are afraid because we tremble. Take away the bodily feelings, he argued, and nothing of the emotion is left. The theory remains a reference point in the psychology of emotion.

Tough and tender. James held that the history of philosophy is to a great extent a clash of temperaments. The tender-minded are rationalist, idealist, optimistic, religious and believers in free will. The tough-minded are empiricist, materialist, pessimistic, irreligious and fatalist. Most people want facts and also want religion, and pragmatism is offered as a method that can satisfy both.

The varieties. His lectures on religion study conversion, saintliness and mysticism from first-person reports. He contrasts the healthy-minded, who see the world as good, with the sick soul, who must be born twice. Mystical states are authoritative for those who have them and not for others. His conclusion is cautious: the conscious person is continuous with a wider self through which saving experiences come.

Works

A common misreading

James did not hold that whatever is pleasant or convenient to believe is true. He required that a true idea agree with reality and be borne out in the long run of experience; critics such as Bertrand Russell nonetheless thought the theory collapsed into that view.

Influenced by

Charles Sanders Peirce, John Stuart Mill, David Hume, Blaise Pascal

Influenced

John Dewey, Edmund Husserl, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Nishida Kitarō, Bertrand Russell

Schools and eras

Pragmatism, 19th Century

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open William James in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.