Blaise Pascal
French mathematician and religious thinker who probed the limits of reason and the wretchedness and greatness of the human condition.
Life
Pascal was a mathematical prodigy, educated at home by his father. As a young man he built a mechanical calculator, carried out experiments on atmospheric pressure and the vacuum, and with Fermat laid the foundations of probability theory.
After an intense religious experience on the night of 23 November 1654, he attached himself to the austere Jansenist community of Port-Royal and defended it in the satirical Provincial Letters. He died at thirty-nine, leaving hundreds of notes for a defence of Christianity, published as the Pensées.
Core ideas
- Reason cannot prove its own first principles; these are known by “the heart”.
- Human beings are a paradox of greatness and wretchedness: a “thinking reed”, weak but aware of its weakness.
- People flee the thought of their condition through diversion.
- Pascal's wager: where reason cannot decide whether God exists, it is rational to stake one's life on belief.
- God is hidden, known through faith and not through metaphysical proof.
In more depth
The condition of man. Pascal describes the human being as suspended between two infinities, the vast and the minute, unable to grasp either. We are a thinking reed: the weakest thing in nature, but nobler than the universe that crushes us, because we know that we die. Human life shows both greatness and wretchedness, and any true account must explain both.
Diversion. People cannot bear to sit quietly in a room, because stillness makes them think of their condition. So they fill life with hunting, gaming, business and conversation. What is sought is not the prize but the chase, which keeps the mind off itself. This analysis of restlessness is among his most original contributions.
Reason and the heart. Against the sceptics, we know first principles such as space, time and number. Against the dogmatists, we cannot prove them. They are known by the heart, by which he means an immediate intuition and not emotion. The heart has its reasons, which reason does not know. Reason's last step is to recognise that an infinity of things lie beyond it.
The wager. Reason cannot decide whether God exists, and not choosing is itself a choice. If you wager that God exists and are right, the gain is infinite; if wrong, the loss is finite. The calculation favours belief. To the reply that one cannot believe at will, Pascal advises acting as believers do until the passions that obstruct belief subside. Critics object that the argument does not say which God to bet on and that belief adopted for gain is not faith.
The hidden God. God gives enough light for those who seek and enough obscurity for those who do not. Christianity alone, he argues, explains the double human condition, through creation and the Fall.
The text. The Pensées are notes for an unfinished defence of Christianity, found after his death and ordered differently by different editors.
The scientist. Before the Pensées Pascal had built a mechanical calculator, written on conic sections at sixteen, and with Fermat laid the foundations of probability theory. He organised the experiment in which a barometer was carried up the Puy de Dôme, showing that the height of the mercury falls with altitude and so that the air has weight and a vacuum is possible. He wrote that in physics experience, and not authority, must decide. His later religious writing keeps the habits of a mathematician.
The night of fire. On the night of 23 November 1654 Pascal underwent an experience that he recorded on a sheet of parchment found sewn into his coat after his death. It begins with the word “Fire” and continues: God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob, not of the philosophers and scholars. Certainty, joy, peace. The contrast between the God reached by proof and the God encountered in history governs everything he wrote afterward.
Two infinities. A long fragment places the human being between the infinitely large and the infinitely small. The visible world is a speck in nature; a mite contains worlds within its smallest parts. We are a middle between nothing and everything, unable to see either the nothing from which we come or the infinite in which we are swallowed. “The eternal silence of these infinite spaces frightens me.” Yet man is a thinking reed: the universe can crush him, but he knows that he dies, and the universe knows nothing of it.
Three orders. Pascal distinguishes the order of bodies, the order of minds and the order of charity. Kings and captains are great in the first, Archimedes in the second, Christ and the saints in the third, and greatness in one order is invisible from the one below. All bodies together cannot produce one thought; all bodies and minds together cannot produce one movement of true charity. The scheme explains why he thinks proofs of God, which belong to the second order, do not produce faith.
In their words
The heart has its reasons, which reason does not know.
Works
- Provincial Letters, 1656–1657
- Pensées, published posthumously, 1670
A common misreading
The Pensées are not a finished book. They are fragments found after his death, and their order differs between editions, which is why fragment numbers must name the edition.
Influenced by
Augustine of Hippo, Michel de Montaigne, René Descartes, Epictetus
Influenced
Søren Kierkegaard, Friedrich Nietzsche, William James
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Blaise Pascal in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.