John Dewey
American pragmatist who treated thinking as problem-solving and made education and democracy central topics of philosophy.
Life
Dewey was born in Burlington, Vermont, and began as a follower of G.W.F. Hegel before turning to a naturalism shaped by Darwin and by William James's psychology. At the University of Chicago he founded an experimental “Laboratory School” in 1896 to test his ideas about learning.
From 1904 he taught at Columbia University in New York. He was the leading American public intellectual of his day, active in causes from teachers' unions to civil liberties, and he lectured for two years in China from 1919. He continued publishing into his nineties.
Core ideas
- Inquiry begins in a problematic situation and ends when the situation is resolved; ideas are instruments for this.
- The “spectator theory of knowledge”, on which knowing is passive beholding, is mistaken.
- Education is growth through experience and activity, not the transmission of fixed content.
- Democracy is a way of associated living and shared inquiry, not only a form of government.
- Ends and means cannot be separated; values are to be tested by their consequences in experience.
In more depth
Experience. Dewey rejects the picture, common to rationalists and earlier empiricists, of a mind that looks out on a world. He begins from a living creature interacting with its environment. Experience is this doing and undergoing. Knowing is one phase of it, which arises when habits are blocked and a situation becomes problematic.
Inquiry. Inquiry is the controlled transformation of an indeterminate situation into a determinate one. It has a pattern: a felt difficulty, its definition as a problem, the suggestion of a solution, reasoning about its consequences, and testing in action. Ideas are instruments, plans of action judged by whether they resolve the difficulty. He preferred to speak of warranted assertibility where others spoke of truth, since every conclusion remains open to revision.
Against the spectator. Philosophy since the Greeks has sought certainty by contemplating an unchanging reality and has ranked theory above practice. He calls this the spectator theory of knowledge and traces it to a society that separated leisure from labour. Experimental science shows that we know by intervening. The dualisms of mind and body, fact and value, individual and society are to be dissolved.
Ethics. Values are not outside the scope of inquiry. What is desired is a fact; what is desirable is a judgement about what will stand up after its conditions and consequences are examined. Ends and means form a continuum, and ends are revised as we act. Growth itself is the only moral end.
Education. Education is a continuous reconstruction of experience. Children learn by engaging in activities that have meaning for them, and the school should be a small community. He later criticised progressive educators who dropped subject matter and guidance altogether.
Democracy. Democracy is more than a form of government. It is a mode of associated living, of shared experience communicated among its members, and the social form of the experimental method.
Art. Aesthetic experience is ordinary experience brought to completion and unity. Art should not be shut away in museums.
Objections. Russell argued that his account of truth confuses what is true with what is useful to believe. Others ask what standard is left for judging growth, since a criminal career also grows.
The life. Dewey was born in Vermont in 1859, the year of Darwin's Origin of Species, and died in 1952. He taught at Michigan, at Chicago, where he ran an experimental school, and for decades at Columbia. He lectured for two years in China, visited Japan, Turkey, Mexico and the Soviet Union, helped to found organisations for civil liberties and for teachers, and at seventy-eight chaired the commission that examined the charges made against Trotsky in the Moscow trials.
The reflex arc. An early paper criticises the psychology that splits behaviour into stimulus, central process and response. A child sees a candle, reaches, and is burned. The seeing is already an act of looking, and the burn changes what the candle is seen as. Stimulus and response are phases within one circuit of coordination, distinguished by their function. The paper contains in small the later philosophy: organism and environment are one system of interaction.
The stages of inquiry. Thinking starts from a felt difficulty, a situation that is unsettled. The next step is to locate and define the problem. Then suggestions for a solution occur and are developed by reasoning into their consequences. Finally one tests by acting and observing. The result of successful inquiry he prefers to call warranted assertibility. Knowledge is not a copy of something antecedent. It is the settled outcome of this process and remains open to revision.
The school. In the Laboratory School children cooked, wove, built and gardened, and through these occupations met arithmetic, chemistry, history and geography as tools for what they were doing. Dewey's creed was that education is a process of living and not a preparation for future living. In Experience and Education he criticised progressive schools that simply let children do as they wished: not all experience educates, and the teacher's task is to arrange experiences that lead to growth.
The public. Answering Walter Lippmann's claim that modern citizens cannot be competent to govern, Dewey argued that the remedy for the ills of democracy is more democracy: better communication and local community life in which people can discuss. In A Common Faith he distinguished the religious, an attitude of devotion to ideal ends, from religions and the supernatural, and kept the first.
Works
- Democracy and Education, 1916
- Experience and Nature, 1925
- The Quest for Certainty, 1929
- Art as Experience, 1934
- Logic: The Theory of Inquiry, 1938
A common misreading
Dewey is blamed for “child-centred” schooling without structure. In Experience and Education (1938) he criticised progressive schools that neglected organised subject matter and the teacher's guiding role.
Influenced by
Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, G.W.F. Hegel
Influenced
Schools and eras
Pragmatism, 20th-Century Global, 19th Century
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open John Dewey in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.