John Stuart Mill
English philosopher who refined utilitarianism and gave the classic defence of individual liberty.
Life
Mill was educated at home by his father, James Mill, a friend of Jeremy Bentham, under a severe regime that had him reading Greek at three. At twenty he suffered a mental crisis, from which he recovered partly through poetry. He worked for thirty-five years in the London office of the East India Company.
He credited Harriet Taylor, whom he married in 1851 after a long friendship, with a large share in his later works. He sat in Parliament from 1865 to 1868, where he proposed extending the vote to women.
Core ideas
- Actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; but pleasures differ in quality, and the higher ones matter more.
- The Harm principle: society may restrict an individual's liberty only to prevent harm to others.
- Free discussion is necessary for discovering truth and for holding it as a living belief.
- All knowledge, including mathematics, rests on induction from experience.
- The legal subordination of women is wrong and a hindrance to human improvement.
In more depth
Logic and induction. Mill holds that all knowledge, including mathematics, rests on experience. Deduction adds nothing new, since the conclusion is already contained in the general premise, which is itself a summary of observed cases. Real inference is from particulars to particulars. His methods of experimental inquiry, of agreement, difference, residues and concomitant variation, are rules for finding causes.
Utilitarianism revised. Actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, which is pleasure and the absence of pain. Against the charge that this is a doctrine fit for swine, Mill argues that pleasures differ in quality as well as quantity. The test is the preference of those who have experienced both. It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied. Critics object that if quality is something other than amount of pleasure, another value has been admitted.
The proof. Mill argues that the only evidence that something is desirable is that people desire it, and each person desires their own happiness. G. E. Moore later charged that this confuses what is desired with what ought to be desired. Mill also grounds justice in utility: rights are claims that society has the strongest utilitarian reasons to protect.
Liberty. The only purpose for which power can rightfully be exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good is not a sufficient warrant. Mill's fear is as much the pressure of opinion as the force of law.
Freedom of thought. To silence an opinion is to assume one's own infallibility. If the opinion is true, we lose the truth. If it is partly true, we lose the part. If it is false, we lose the clearer understanding that comes from its collision with error; a truth never contested becomes a dead dogma.
Individuality. Human nature is not a machine to be built after a model. It is a tree that needs to grow according to its inward forces. Experiments in living benefit everyone.
Women and government. The Subjection of Women argues that the legal subordination of one sex to the other is wrong in itself and a chief hindrance to human improvement, and that nothing can be known about women's nature while it is so distorted. He favoured representative government with safeguards for educated opinion.
A tension. Whether the liberty principle can really be derived from utility, or whether Mill valued freedom for its own sake, is the central question about his work.
The education and the crisis. Mill was taught by his father, James Mill, on a plan drawn from Bentham: Greek at three, Latin at eight, logic at twelve, political economy at thirteen. At twenty he asked himself whether he would be happy if all his aims for reform were achieved, and had to answer no. The depression that followed lifted when he read the poetry of Wordsworth. He concluded that the cultivation of feeling is as necessary as analysis, and that happiness is found only by aiming at something else.
The four methods. The System of Logic sets out canons for finding causes. Agreement: if all cases of a phenomenon share one circumstance, that is the cause. Difference: if a case where it occurs and a case where it does not differ in one circumstance only, that is the cause or part of it. Residues: subtract what is already explained. Concomitant variation: what varies with it is connected with it. A joint method combines the first two. They remain the basic logic of the controlled experiment.
Socrates dissatisfied. It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied. If the fool or the pig thinks otherwise, it is because they know only their own side of the question. The test of a higher pleasure is the preference of those who have experienced both. Critics say that if the judges prefer something for reasons other than its pleasantness, Mill has abandoned hedonism.
The limits of the harm principle. The only purpose for which power can rightly be used over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant. Mill applies it carefully: one may warn a man about to cross an unsafe bridge, and stop him if there is no time to warn; one may not sell oneself into slavery, since liberty does not include the freedom to give up liberty. He excluded children and, notoriously, “backward” societies.
Harriet Taylor and public life. Mill said that his later works were joint productions with Harriet Taylor, whom he married in 1851 after twenty years of friendship. He worked for the East India Company for thirty-five years. As a member of Parliament he moved in 1867 to give women the vote, the first such proposal in the Commons.
In their words
It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied.
Works
- A System of Logic, 1843
- On Liberty, 1859
- Utilitarianism, 1861
- The Subjection of Women, 1869
- Autobiography, 1873
Where scholars disagree
Whether the liberalism of On Liberty is consistent with his utilitarianism, and whether he was an act or a rule utilitarian, are standing debates.
A common misreading
Mill's defence of liberty is sometimes read as resting on natural rights. He explicitly declines that basis in On Liberty and argues from utility “in the largest sense”.
Influenced by
Jeremy Bentham, David Hume, Auguste Comte, Mary Wollstonecraft, Adam Smith
Influenced
Bertrand Russell, John Rawls, William James
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Utilitarianism, Empiricism, 19th Century
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open John Stuart Mill in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.