Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Nishida Kitarō

1870 CE – 1945 CE · Ishikawa and Kyoto, Japan · Japanese

Founder of the Kyoto School and Japan's most influential modern philosopher, who brought Zen experience into dialogue with Western philosophy.

Also known as: Kitaro Nishida, 西田幾多郎

Life

Nishida was born near Kanazawa on the Sea of Japan coast. He worked for a decade as a schoolteacher, during which he practised Zen meditation intensively and read widely in European philosophy. His first book, An Inquiry into the Good, appeared in 1911.

He taught at Kyoto Imperial University from 1910 until his retirement in 1928, gathering the circle of students later known as the Kyoto School, and went on developing his thought until his death shortly before the end of the Second World War.

Core ideas

In more depth

Pure experience. Nishida's first book starts from experience as it is before reflection divides it. In the moment of seeing a colour or hearing a sound there is not yet a subject who sees and an object seen. That division comes afterwards, through thought. Pure experience is the one reality, and the individual exists because there is experience, not the reverse. The idea owes something to William James and something to Zen practice.

Self-awareness. He came to think that this starting point sounded too psychological. His next work describes reality as a self-aware system, one that mirrors itself within itself, as in the thought of a map of a country drawn within that country and including the map.

Place. His mature philosophy asks where things and judgements are located. In a judgement the subject is placed within the predicate, the particular within the universal. Western philosophy, following Aristotle, took as fundamental the subject that cannot be a predicate, the individual substance. Nishida moves in the opposite direction, toward a predicate that cannot be a subject, the field within which everything is determined. He calls this basho, place.

Absolute nothingness. Places are nested: the place of physical being, then the field of consciousness, and finally the place of absolute nothingness. This last is not a thing and not mere absence. It is that within which being and relative non-being both arise, and which determines itself without a determiner. Here he gives philosophical form to the Buddhist notion of emptiness.

Contradictory self-identity. In his last period he describes the historical world as the self-identity of absolute contradictories: the one and the many, the individual and the environment, each making the other. We act by intuition, forming the world while being formed by it.

Religion. His final essay holds that the self meets the absolute only through its own self-negation, and the absolute contains its own negation, a relation he calls inverse correspondence (also translated inverse correlation).

Criticism. Tanabe objected that the logic of place rests on intuition and neglects the mediation of society and history. Nishida's wartime writings on the state and the imperial house remain disputed between those who see resistance within the terms allowed and those who see accommodation.

The life. Nishida was born in 1870 near Kanazawa, was a school friend of D. T. Suzuki, and for a decade practised Zen meditation intensively while teaching in provincial schools. An Inquiry into the Good, published in 1911, made his name, and he taught at Kyoto University until 1928. His life was marked by the deaths of his first wife and of several children. A canal path in Kyoto where he walked is called the Philosopher's Path. He died in June 1945, two months before the end of the war.

The moment of pure experience. His examples are the instant of seeing a colour or hearing a sound before one has judged what it is or thought of oneself as seeing, and the absorption of a musician playing a practised piece or a climber on a cliff. There is not first a self that then has an experience. Experience comes first, and the individual is differentiated within it. He took the term from William James and gave it a meaning shaped by his practice.

The logic of the predicate. Aristotle defined substance as the subject that is never a predicate. Nishida reverses the direction. In a judgement the particular is placed within the universal, as red within colour. Consciousness, he says, is that which becomes a predicate and never a subject: the field in which things are. Following this through wider and wider fields leads to a place that is itself nothing, which contains all and can be the object of no judgement.

Acting intuition. In his later work the model is the maker. We see things by acting on them, and we are shaped by the things we have made; he says that we move from the made to the making. The historical world forms itself through the bodies of individuals, who are its creative elements. This answered critics who found the earlier philosophy too contemplative, and it draws him closer to questions of society and history.

I and thou and the war. In an essay of 1932 he holds that the self knows itself only by meeting another who is absolutely other, across a discontinuity. During the war he wrote on the national polity and was consulted by officials; scholars disagree on whether these texts resist or serve the ideology of the time. His circle, including Tanabe and Nishitani, is known as the Kyoto School.

Works

Where scholars disagree

His wartime writings on the Japanese state and the imperial household have been read both as complicity with nationalism and as an attempt to resist it from within. The question remains contested.

A common misreading

Nishida's philosophy is not simply Zen restated. He rarely cites Buddhist texts, argues throughout in the terms of Western philosophy, and intended his work as philosophy in the universal sense.

Influenced by

William James, G.W.F. Hegel, Immanuel Kant, Dōgen, Nagarjuna

Related ideas

Absolute nothingness

Schools and eras

Kyoto School, Zen, 20th-Century Global

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Nishida Kitarō in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.