Henry Sidgwick
Cambridge philosopher whose Methods of Ethics is the most careful statement of classical utilitarianism and of its limits.
Life
Sidgwick spent his life at Cambridge. In 1869 he resigned his fellowship because he could no longer subscribe to the articles of the Church of England, an act that helped to end the religious tests. He worked for the higher education of women and was a founder of Newnham College, of which his wife Eleanor became principal. He was also the first president of the Society for Psychical Research.
Core ideas
- There are three methods of ethics: egoism, intuitionism and utilitarianism.
- Common-sense morality is unconsciously utilitarian, and utilitarianism systematises it.
- Ethics rests on a few self-evident axioms of prudence, justice and benevolence.
- The good of any one individual is of no more importance, from the point of view of the universe, than the good of any other.
- Practical reason is divided: neither egoism nor utilitarianism can be shown to override the other.
In more depth
The method of the Methods. Sidgwick does not preach a doctrine. He examines the reasoning by which people decide what they ought to do and finds three coherent procedures. One aims at the agent's own greatest happiness. One follows the rules of common-sense morality, such as truthfulness, justice and good faith, taken as self-evident. One aims at the greatest happiness of all. The book tests each with unusual patience, and John Rawls and Derek Parfit both ranked it among the best works of moral philosophy ever written.
Common sense examined. Take the duty to keep promises. Is it binding if the promise was obtained by fraud, if circumstances have changed completely, if keeping it would harm the person promised? Common sense gives no clear answer, and where it hesitates it appeals to consequences. Sidgwick concludes that the rules of ordinary morality are not self-evident axioms. They are rough guides whose exceptions and limits are settled by considering general happiness. But a few abstract principles do pass the test of self-evidence: that I should not prefer a present lesser good to a future greater one, that what is right for me is right for anyone similar, and that I should aim at good generally.
The dualism. The last chapter does not end in triumph. It is reasonable to seek the general happiness. It is also reasonable to seek one's own. Usually these coincide; sometimes they do not, and reason cannot say which should yield unless the universe is so ordered that virtue is rewarded. Sidgwick could find no proof of that. He also discussed whether utilitarianism might be best kept as a doctrine for an enlightened few, a suggestion Bernard Williams later attacked as “Government House” ethics.
Works
- The Methods of Ethics, 1874
- The Principles of Political Economy, 1883
- Outlines of the History of Ethics, 1886
- The Elements of Politics, 1891
Influenced by
John Stuart Mill, Jeremy Bentham, Immanuel Kant, Aristotle
Influenced
G.E. Moore, John Rawls, Derek Parfit, Peter Singer
Related ideas
Consequentialism, Principle of utility
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Henry Sidgwick in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.