John Rawls
American philosopher whose theory of “justice as fairness” revived political philosophy in the late twentieth century.
Life
Rawls was born in Baltimore and studied at Princeton. He served as an infantryman in the Pacific in the Second World War and saw the ruins of Hiroshima, experiences that ended his plan to enter the ministry.
He taught at Cornell and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology before joining Harvard in 1962, where he spent the rest of his career. He worked on the ideas of A Theory of Justice for some twenty years before publishing it in 1971.
Core ideas
- Principles of justice are those that free and equal persons would choose in an “original position” behind a Veil of ignorance.
- First principle: each person has an equal claim to a full scheme of basic liberties.
- Second principle: inequalities must be attached to positions open to all under fair equality of opportunity, and must benefit the least advantaged (the difference principle).
- Reflective equilibrium: principles and considered judgements are adjusted to one another.
- In a pluralist society, a political conception of justice must be the object of an “overlapping consensus”.
In more depth
The question. Rawls asks what principles should govern the basic structure of society, its main political and economic institutions, given that these shape everyone's prospects from birth. He wanted an alternative to utilitarianism, which he held does not take seriously the distinction between persons, since it allows losses to some to be outweighed by gains to others.
The original position. The principles of justice are those that free and rational persons would agree to in a fair situation of choice. Fairness is secured by a veil of ignorance. The parties do not know their class, race, sex, talents or conception of the good. They do know general facts about society. Since no one can tailor principles to their own advantage, the result of the agreement is fair. Hence the name justice as fairness.
The two principles. First, each person has an equal claim to a fully adequate scheme of equal basic liberties. Second, social and economic inequalities must be attached to positions open to all under fair equality of opportunity, and must be to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged; this last is the difference principle. The first principle has priority: liberty may not be traded for economic gain.
Why these. Under such uncertainty, and with so much at stake, Rawls argues it is rational to secure the best worst outcome. He adds that natural talents and social starting points are arbitrary from a moral point of view, so no one deserves the advantages they bring.
Reflective equilibrium. Principles are tested against considered judgements about cases, and each is adjusted in light of the other until they cohere.
Political liberalism. His later work addresses the fact that citizens of a free society will always hold different religious and philosophical doctrines. Justice as fairness is recast as a political conception that can be the focus of an overlapping consensus, and public questions are to be argued in terms all can accept.
Critics. Nozick objected that the theory treats goods as if they fell from heaven with no prior entitlements. Harsanyi argued the parties would maximise average utility. Communitarians such as Sandel objected to the picture of a self prior to its ends, and Okin that the family was left out. G. A. Cohen argued the difference principle permits too much inequality.
The life. Rawls grew up in Baltimore; two of his brothers died in childhood of infections they caught from him, which he later connected with his sense of the arbitrariness of fortune. He served as an infantryman in the Pacific and saw the ruins of Hiroshima. He taught at Harvard for more than thirty years, avoided publicity, and declined most honours. A Theory of Justice, published in 1971 after twenty years of work, revived political philosophy as a systematic subject.
The four-way comparison. Rawls considers how the basic structure might distribute advantages. A system of natural liberty leaves outcomes to open competition and so to inherited wealth and talent. Liberal equality corrects for social class through fair equality of opportunity but still rewards native endowment. Natural aristocracy asks the gifted to help the poor. Democratic equality combines fair opportunity with the difference principle. Since no one deserves their starting place or their natural talents, he argues, only the last treats people as equals.
Maximin. Why would the parties choose by looking to the worst outcome? Rawls gives three conditions under which it is rational: when probabilities cannot be known, when the minimum guaranteed is satisfactory, and when the alternatives carry outcomes one could hardly accept. Behind the veil all three hold. The parties choose once, for their whole lives and for their descendants, and must be able to keep the agreement in good faith whatever position they turn out to hold.
The priority of liberty and the primary goods. The parties compare societies by an index of primary goods: rights and liberties, opportunities, income and wealth, and the social bases of self-respect, which Rawls calls perhaps the most important. The basic liberties come first and may be limited only for the sake of liberty, not for economic gain. Critics such as Sen replied that people differ in their ability to turn goods into what they can do and be, so that goods are the wrong measure.
Stability and the later Rawls. A just society must generate its own support. In Political Liberalism Rawls admitted that his first account assumed citizens would share one moral outlook, which is unrealistic in a free society. He now sought a conception that people of differing reasonable faiths and philosophies could each endorse from within their own view. The Law of Peoples extends the idea to relations among societies.
Works
- A Theory of Justice, 1971
- Political Liberalism, 1993
- The Law of Peoples, 1999
- Justice as Fairness: A Restatement, 2001
A common misreading
The difference principle does not require equal incomes. It permits inequalities, including large ones, whenever they work to the benefit of the worst-off group.
Influenced by
Immanuel Kant, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, John Locke, John Stuart Mill, Thomas Hobbes
Influenced
Robert Nozick, Jürgen Habermas, Derek Parfit
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open John Rawls in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.