Bernard Williams
English moral philosopher, the leading critic of systematic ethical theory in the late twentieth century.
Life
Williams read classics at Oxford, flew Spitfires during national service, and held chairs at London, Cambridge, Berkeley and Oxford. He chaired a government committee on obscenity and film censorship. He wrote on personal identity, on Descartes, on opera, and on the Greeks, and was known for the speed and wit of his conversation.
Core ideas
- Utilitarianism cannot account for a person's integrity, the commitments that make a life one's own.
- Moral luck: the justification of a life may depend on how things turn out.
- Internal reasons: a person has a reason to act only if it connects with motives they already have.
- Morality, as a system of inescapable obligation and blame, is a peculiar institution we would be better without.
- Thick concepts such as courage and cruelty both describe and guide action.
In more depth
Jim and the Indians. Jim, a botanist, arrives in a South American town where a captain is about to shoot twenty Indians. As an honoured guest he is offered the chance to shoot one himself, in which case the rest will go free. George, a chemist who opposes chemical weapons, is offered a job in a weapons laboratory; if he refuses, a zealous rival will take it. Utilitarianism says both should accept. Williams does not say Jim should refuse. His point is that the theory treats the answer as obvious and has no room for the fact that these would be their own acts.
Integrity. People have projects and attachments with which they are deeply identified. Utilitarianism regards each person as a channel between the input of everyone's projects and an output of optimal decisions. To demand that a man step aside from his own commitments whenever the sums require is to alienate him from his actions and the source of them in his convictions. It is, in the most literal sense, an attack on his integrity. A related remark: a man who saves his wife and pauses to check that it is permissible has had one thought too many.
Gauguin. A painter leaves his wife and children to pursue his art in the South Seas. He cannot know that he will succeed. If he fails, he has no basis for thinking he was justified. If he succeeds, he may. So the justification depends on luck, and this is at odds with the idea that moral worth is immune to fortune.
The peculiar institution. In his main book Williams distinguishes ethics, the wide question of how one should live, from morality, a narrow system built on obligation, voluntariness and blame. Morality promises that what matters most is equally available to all and beyond luck. He thinks this is an illusion. Ethical knowledge exists within a way of life, through thick concepts, and reflection can destroy it. In Shame and Necessity he argued that the Greeks' ideas of responsibility were in some ways sounder than ours.
Works
- Morality: An Introduction to Ethics, 1972
- A Critique of Utilitarianism, 1973
- Moral Luck, 1981
- Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy, 1985
- Shame and Necessity, 1993
- Truth and Truthfulness, 2002
Influenced by
Friedrich Nietzsche, Aristotle, David Hume, Gilbert Ryle
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Bernard Williams in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.