Peter Singer
Australian utilitarian who argued for the equal consideration of animals and for demanding duties to the distant poor.
Life
Singer's parents were Jewish refugees from Vienna; three of his grandparents died in the Holocaust. He studied at Melbourne and Oxford, where he was taught by R. M. Hare, taught at Monash University, and since 1999 has held a chair in bioethics at Princeton. His views on euthanasia and severely disabled infants have led to protests against his lectures.
Core ideas
- Equal consideration of interests: the same suffering counts the same whoever feels it.
- Speciesism, favouring the interests of one's own species as such, is a prejudice like racism.
- If we can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought to do it.
- Distance and the number of other possible helpers make no moral difference.
- Ethics should be based on reasoning, not on unexamined intuitions.
In more depth
The drowning child. Walking past a shallow pond, you see a small child drowning. To wade in will ruin your shoes and make you late. Nearly everyone agrees you must do it. Singer then asks what the difference is between this child and a child dying of an easily preventable disease in a distant country, whose life could be saved for the price of the shoes. That the second child is far away, or that others could also help, does not change what is at stake. The conclusion is that giving to effective aid is a duty, not charity, and that much ordinary spending is wrong.
How much. The strong version of the principle requires giving until giving more would cause as much suffering to oneself as it relieves. Singer accepts that this is very demanding and holds that the demandingness is no objection. In later writing he proposes a public standard that people might actually follow, a sliding percentage of income, and has helped to inspire the movement known as effective altruism, which tries to find where a donation does the most good.
Animals. All the arguments for human equality, he argues, rest on the capacity to suffer and to enjoy, not on intelligence or species. The capacity to suffer is the condition of having interests at all. To give less weight to an animal's pain because it is not human is speciesism. Singer does not say animals have rights, or that all lives are of equal value. He says like interests must be counted alike. The book describes factory farming and laboratory testing in detail and concludes that both are indefensible.
Persons and the hardest cases. Singer distinguishes being a member of the human species from being a person: a being aware of itself as existing over time. Killing a person is wrong chiefly because it thwarts their preferences about the future. Since newborn infants are not yet persons in this sense, he has argued that ending the life of a severely disabled newborn can be permissible. Disability advocates have objected strongly that the argument devalues disabled lives.
Works
- Famine, Affluence, and Morality, 1972
- Animal Liberation, 1975
- Practical Ethics, 1979
- The Life You Can Save, 2009
Influenced by
Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill, Henry Sidgwick
Related ideas
Consequentialism, Principle of utility
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Peter Singer in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.