Jeremy Bentham
English legal reformer and founder of utilitarianism, who judged every law and action by its tendency to promote happiness.
Life
Bentham was a child prodigy who entered Oxford at twelve and trained for the law, which he never practised. Appalled by the confusion of English law, he devoted his life to its reform and to designing rational codes, prisons and institutions. He spent years promoting the Panopticon, a prison built for constant inspection, which was never constructed.
He wrote daily for decades and left tens of thousands of manuscript pages. Much was published by disciples. At his request his body was dissected and preserved as an “auto-icon”, which is kept at University College London.
Core ideas
- The Principle of utility: actions and laws are right in so far as they promote the greatest happiness of those affected.
- Pleasure and pain are the only things good and bad in themselves, and can in principle be measured.
- Each person's happiness counts equally.
- Natural rights are “nonsense upon stilts”; real rights are created by law.
- Because animals can suffer, their interests count.
In more depth
The principle. Nature, Bentham writes, has placed mankind under two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure. They determine both what we will do and what we ought to do. The principle of utility approves or disapproves of every action according to its tendency to increase or diminish the happiness of those whose interest is in question. It applies to private conduct and above all to legislation.
Measuring. The value of a pleasure or pain depends on its intensity, duration, certainty and nearness, on its tendency to be followed by more of the same or by its opposite, and on the number of people it reaches. The legislator should sum these for everyone affected. Bentham recognised that the sum cannot be done exactly; it sets the form of the reasoning.
No pleasure is higher. All pleasures are of one kind and differ only in quantity. He is reported to have said that, prejudice apart, the game of push-pin is of equal value with poetry. Each person counts for one and none for more than one. Since the capacity to suffer is what matters, the interests of animals count too.
Against natural rights. Rights are the creatures of law. To speak of natural rights is nonsense, and of natural and imprescriptible rights, nonsense upon stilts. Such talk substitutes assertion for the calculation of consequences. He also attacked legal fictions and the unwritten common law.
Law and punishment. All punishment is in itself an evil and is justified only if it prevents a greater one. It should be no heavier than is needed to deter. The Panopticon, a circular prison in which inmates may be observed at any time without knowing when, was his design for efficient reform. He argued for codified law, wider suffrage, and the decriminalisation of homosexual acts.
Objections. Critics hold that the theory would permit sacrificing an individual whenever the total gained, that pleasures cannot be measured on one scale, and that it ignores the separateness of persons. Mill's revision was a response to the second.
The seven dimensions. To value a pleasure or pain for one person, Bentham says, consider its intensity, its duration, its certainty and its nearness in time. To value the act that produces it, add fecundity, the chance it will be followed by more of the same kind, and purity, the chance it will not be followed by the opposite. For a group add extent, the number of people affected. Sum the pleasures and pains for each person and then across persons. He did not expect a strict calculation in every case, only that it be kept in view.
Fictions and paraphrasis. Bentham held that much confusion in law and morals comes from treating words like “right”, “duty” and “obligation” as names of things. They are fictions. A sentence containing such a word must be translated whole into a sentence about real entities: to have a duty is to be liable to pain if one does not act. This method of analysing sentences and not single words anticipates techniques used by Russell and later analytic philosophers.
Animals, sex and usury. Because the principle counts all pleasure and pain, it reaches cases others excluded. Of animals he wrote: the question is not, can they reason, nor can they talk, but can they suffer? In essays unpublished in his lifetime he argued that homosexual acts harm no one and should not be punished. He defended lending at interest against Adam Smith, and argued for the equal treatment of women, though he thought the public not ready for their voting.
The reformer and the Auto-Icon. Bentham drafted codes of law for any nation that would have them and coined the words “international”, “codify” and “maximise”. Disappointed by governments, he came to believe that rulers pursue their own interest and that only democratic accountability aligns it with the general interest. He left his body to be dissected and preserved; the dressed skeleton with a wax head sits in a cabinet at University College London.
In their words
The question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?
Works
- A Fragment on Government, 1776
- An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, printed 1780; published 1789
- Panopticon, 1791
A common misreading
Bentham did not found University College London. He inspired its founders and never took part in establishing it.
Influenced by
David Hume, Epicurus, Thomas Hobbes
Influenced
John Stuart Mill, Derek Parfit
Related ideas
Principle of utility, Consequentialism
Schools and eras
Utilitarianism, Enlightenment, 19th Century
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Jeremy Bentham in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.