Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Genevan thinker who argued that society corrupts natural human goodness and that legitimate authority rests on the general will.
Life
Rousseau was born in Geneva and left it at sixteen, living for years as a wanderer, servant, music teacher and secretary. In Paris he befriended Diderot and contributed to the Encyclopédie. In 1750 he won sudden fame with a prize essay arguing that the progress of the arts and sciences had corrupted morals.
In 1762 Emile was condemned in Paris, and both it and The Social Contract were condemned in Geneva; he fled. Years of exile followed, including a stay in England arranged by David Hume, which ended in a bitter quarrel. His Confessions, published after his death, helped create modern autobiography.
Core ideas
- Human beings are naturally good, with self-love and pity; inequality and vice arise with property and social comparison.
- The problem of politics is to find a form of association in which each, uniting with all, obeys only himself.
- Legitimate law expresses the General will, which aims at the common good.
- Sovereignty belongs to the people and cannot be represented.
- Education should follow the child's natural development (Emile).
In more depth
The diagnosis. Rousseau holds that human beings are good by nature and are made wicked by their institutions. His first Discourse argues that progress in the arts and sciences has corrupted morals. The second gives a conjectural history. Natural man is solitary, has few needs, and is moved by self-preservation and pity. He is neither moral nor vicious.
How inequality arose. With settled life people begin to compare themselves, and a second kind of self-love appears, amour-propre, which depends on the opinion of others. Property follows. The first person who fenced a piece of land, said this is mine, and found people simple enough to believe him was the founder of civil society. The rich then proposed laws to protect what they had seized, and the poor ran to meet their chains.
The social contract. Man is born free and everywhere he is in chains. The question of the Social Contract is what could make political authority legitimate. The answer is an association in which each gives himself entirely to the whole community, and so, since all do the same, obeys only himself. The people as a body is sovereign, and its will is the general will, aimed at the common good.
The general will. It is distinct from the will of all, which is only the sum of private interests. Sovereignty cannot be represented or divided; the people must make the laws themselves, while government merely executes them. Whoever refuses to obey the general will shall be compelled to do so by the whole body, which Rousseau glosses as being forced to be free. That phrase is the source of the charge that his theory licenses tyranny. Defenders reply that he means only that law binds everyone who helped to make it.
Education. Emile describes an education that follows nature: the child learns from things and experience, not from books and commands, and reasoning comes late. The aim is a person who can live in society without being corrupted by it. The treatment of Sophie's education for the sake of pleasing men was attacked by Wollstonecraft.
Tensions. Readers have always found it hard to reconcile the celebrant of individual freedom with the theorist of a demanding civic unity. He did not use the phrase noble savage.
The road to Vincennes. In 1749, walking to visit Diderot in prison, Rousseau read in a newspaper the question set by the Academy of Dijon: has the restoration of the sciences and arts tended to purify morals? He says that he saw another universe and became another man, and sat under a tree in tears. All his later work, he claimed, unfolds from that moment: man is naturally good, and it is by institutions alone that people become wicked.
Two kinds of self-love. Rousseau distinguishes love of self, a natural concern for one's own preservation that is always good, from the self-love that arises only in society and consists in comparing oneself with others and wanting to be preferred. From the second come honour and vanity, the wish to appear what one is not, and the dependence of each person on the opinion of others. The savage lives within himself; social man lives always outside himself.
The lawgiver and civil religion. A people needs good laws to become capable of making them. The Social Contract resolves the circle with the figure of the lawgiver, a wise founder like Lycurgus, who frames the constitution and holds no power under it, and who must appeal to divine authority because he cannot yet persuade by reason. The last chapter proposes a civil religion with a few simple articles, including the sanctity of the contract. Whoever publicly accepts and then acts against them may be punished.
The Savoyard vicar and the Confessions. Book IV of Emile contains a profession of faith by a country priest: I know that I exist, that the world is ordered by a will, and that conscience is a divine instinct, an infallible judge of good and evil. Dogmas and revelations are set aside. The book was condemned in Paris and Geneva, and Rousseau fled. His Confessions, written in exile, begins with the claim to show a man in all the truth of nature, and established modern autobiography.
In their words
Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains.
Works
- Discourse on the Sciences and Arts, written 1750; published 1751
- Discourse on the Origin of Inequality, 1755
- The Social Contract, 1762
- Emile, or On Education, 1762
- Confessions, published posthumously, 1782–1789
Where scholars disagree
Rousseau has been read both as a champion of democratic freedom and as a forerunner of totalitarianism, chiefly on the strength of his remark that whoever refuses to obey the general will must be “forced to be free”.
A common misreading
Rousseau did not use the phrase “noble savage” and did not urge a return to the state of nature. He regarded that state as lost for good and asked how freedom could be recovered within society.
Influenced by
Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, Montesquieu, Niccolò Machiavelli, Michel de Montaigne
Influenced
Immanuel Kant, G.W.F. Hegel, Karl Marx, Mary Wollstonecraft, John Rawls
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Jean-Jacques Rousseau in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.