Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Niccolò Machiavelli

1469 CE – 1527 CE · Florence, Italy · European

Florentine official and writer who analysed politics in terms of power and necessity instead of moral ideals.

Life

Machiavelli served the Florentine republic from 1498 as a secretary and diplomat, observing at first hand rulers such as Cesare Borgia. When the Medici family returned to power in 1512 he was dismissed, and the next year he was imprisoned and tortured on suspicion of conspiracy.

Released, he retired to his farm outside Florence and wrote the works for which he is known, along with plays and a history of Florence. The Prince circulated in manuscript and was printed only after his death.

Core ideas

In more depth

The break. Earlier books of advice for rulers described how a good prince should behave. Machiavelli says he will write about the effectual truth of things, how people actually live and not how they ought to. Someone who tries to be good in all circumstances will come to ruin among so many who are not good. A ruler must therefore learn how not to be good, and use that knowledge or not as necessity requires.

Virtù and fortune. Virtù in his usage is the capacity to do what the situation demands: boldness, foresight, flexibility, readiness to use force and fraud. Fortune governs perhaps half of what happens, like a river in flood, but dykes can be built in quiet times. Success belongs to those whose way of proceeding fits the times, and failure follows when the times change and the person does not.

Appearances and cruelty. A prince should seem merciful, faithful and religious, and should be so when possible, but must be able to act otherwise. It is safer to be feared than loved, provided one avoids being hated. Cruelty is well used when it is done all at once, out of necessity, and not continued.

The republican. The Discourses on Livy, a longer work, argues that republics are more stable and more glorious than principalities, because the people are better guardians of liberty than the great. The conflict between the two classes in Rome, far from being a weakness, produced the laws that kept Rome free. Good arms, good laws and a religion that supports civic spirit are the foundations.

The puzzle. How the author of The Prince and the author of the Discourses are one writer is the standing question. Some hold that both books teach how to found and preserve a state in different conditions. Others read The Prince as ironic or as a bid for employment. He remains the first to treat politics as having its own rules, distinct from those of private morality.

The occasion. Machiavelli served the Florentine republic for fourteen years as a secretary and diplomat, observing Cesare Borgia, the king of France and Pope Julius II at first hand. When the Medici returned in 1512 he was dismissed, then arrested and tortured on suspicion of conspiracy, and retired to his farm. A famous letter describes his days: quarrels and card games at the inn, and in the evening, dressed in the robes of court, he enters his study to converse with the ancients. The Prince was written there.

The lion and the fox. A ruler, he writes, must know how to use the nature of the beast as well as that of man. The lion cannot protect himself from traps and the fox cannot defend himself from wolves, so one must be a fox to recognise traps and a lion to frighten wolves. A prudent ruler cannot keep his word when keeping it would turn against him and the reasons for giving it no longer hold. The model is Cesare Borgia, who had his own harsh governor cut in two in the public square once the man had done his work.

Is it better to be loved or feared. One would wish to be both, but since they are hard to combine, it is much safer to be feared. Love is held by a bond of obligation that people break whenever it suits them; fear is held by dread of punishment, which never fails. But the prince must avoid being hated, which he does by leaving his subjects' property and women alone. People sooner forget the death of a father than the loss of an inheritance.

Religion and arms. In the Discourses Machiavelli treats religion as an instrument of order: the Romans' fear of the gods kept armies obedient and the people united. Christianity, as it has been interpreted, has taught humility and contempt for worldly things and so left the world a prey to the wicked. He also insists that a state must rely on its own citizens under arms; mercenaries are useless and dangerous. His Art of War was the only major work published in his lifetime.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Readers have never agreed about how The Prince relates to the republican Discourses. It has been read as sincere advice, as a bid for employment, and as a covert warning against tyranny.

A common misreading

“The end justifies the means” does not appear in his writings. The nearest passage (The Prince, ch. 18) says that in the actions of princes people look to the outcome.

Influenced by

Cicero, Lucretius

Influenced

Thomas Hobbes, Francis Bacon, Baruch Spinoza, Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Schools and eras

Renaissance

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Niccolò Machiavelli in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.