Montesquieu
French jurist who compared the world's forms of government and argued that liberty requires the separation of powers.
Life
Montesquieu was born at the château of La Brède near Bordeaux and inherited a title and a judicial office in the Bordeaux parlement. He made his name with the Persian Letters, a satire in which two Persian travellers describe French society. He then sold his office and travelled for three years, including eighteen months in England.
He spent the following two decades on The Spirit of the Laws, published anonymously in 1748. It was an immediate success, and the Catholic Church placed it on the Index of Prohibited Books in 1751.
Core ideas
- Laws should be understood in relation to a people's climate, economy, religion and customs.
- There are three forms of government, each with its animating principle: republics (virtue), monarchies (honour) and despotisms (fear).
- Political liberty depends on separating legislative, executive and judicial power, so that “power checks power”.
- Commerce softens manners and inclines nations to peace.
In more depth
Laws as relations. Montesquieu defines laws in the widest sense as the necessary relations that derive from the nature of things. The positive laws of a people are not arbitrary. They are related to its form of government, its climate and soil, its way of life, its religion, commerce and customs. The spirit of the laws is the sum of these relations, and the task is to explain why laws that suit one nation do not suit another.
Three governments. He classifies governments by who holds power and by the passion that makes each work. In a republic the people or part of it governs, and the principle is virtue, meaning love of country and of equality. In a monarchy one person governs by fixed laws, and the principle is honour, the ambition of ranks. In a despotism one person governs by will and caprice, and the principle is fear. A government is corrupted when its principle decays.
Liberty and the separation of powers. Political liberty is not doing what one likes. It is the security each citizen has that power will not be abused. Since anyone with power tends to abuse it, power must check power. When the same body makes the laws, executes them and judges cases, there is no liberty. His account of the English constitution as dividing these three functions was partly idealised, but it shaped the constitution of the United States.
Climate and commerce. He argued that climate affects temperament and so institutions, a thesis criticised even in his own day for crude determinism, though he held that good legislation works against the vices of climate. Commerce, he thought, softens manners and inclines nations to peace.
Method. He condemned slavery and religious persecution, but his main legacy is the attempt to study societies comparatively, as systems with causes, which earned him a place among the founders of sociology.
The Persian Letters. Montesquieu's first success, published anonymously in 1721, is a novel in letters. Two Persian travellers in Paris describe French customs with the astonishment of outsiders: the king is a great magician who makes people believe paper is money; the pope is an old idol worshipped out of habit. Meanwhile letters from home show the despotism of the traveller's own harem, which ends in revolt. The device teaches the method of his later work: see your own institutions as one arrangement among possible others.
The Romans. His Considerations on the Causes of the Greatness of the Romans and their Decline, of 1734, explains history without providence or great men. It is not fortune that rules the world, he writes. There are general causes, moral and physical, at work in every monarchy; if the chance of one battle ruined a state, there was a general cause that made the state such that it could perish by a single battle. The book is an early exercise in structural historical explanation.
The spirit of the laws. Laws should fit the people for whom they are made: the nature and principle of the government, the climate, the soil, the way of life, the religion, the wealth, the numbers, the commerce and the manners. The relations among all these together make up what he calls the spirit of the laws. The legislator therefore cannot simply deduce the best laws from reason. This comparative and empirical approach makes him a founder of sociology and a critic of abstract rationalism in politics.
Slavery and punishment. One chapter lists arguments for enslaving Africans, each more absurd than the last: sugar would be too dear; they are black from head to foot; it is impossible that we should suppose these creatures to be men, since if we did, one would begin to believe that we ourselves are not Christians. The irony was missed by some readers. He also argued that severity of punishment is suited to despotism, and that moderate governments should make penalties proportionate, a theme taken up by Beccaria.
Works
- Persian Letters, 1721
- Considerations on the Causes of the Greatness of the Romans and their Decline, 1734
- The Spirit of the Laws, 1748
A common misreading
His account of the English constitution as a strict separation of powers was idealised. In practice, ministers sat in Parliament then as now, and scholars debate how far he intended a description.
Influenced by
John Locke, Niccolò Machiavelli, Aristotle, Cicero
Influenced
Jean-Jacques Rousseau, David Hume, Edmund Burke, G.W.F. Hegel
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Montesquieu in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.