Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Thomas Hobbes

1588 CE – 1679 CE · Malmesbury and London, England; Paris · European

English materialist who argued that only an absolute sovereign, authorised by a social contract, can rescue people from a war of all against all.

Life

Hobbes was born in Wiltshire in the year of the Spanish Armada and educated at Oxford. He spent most of his life as tutor and secretary to the Cavendish family, which gave him access to books and to continental travel. In his forties he discovered geometry and resolved to apply its method to politics.

Fearing the coming civil war, he left for Paris in 1640 and stayed eleven years, writing Leviathan there. After his return he was repeatedly accused of atheism, and Parliament investigated his book. He remained active into his nineties.

Core ideas

In more depth

Materialism. Hobbes holds that everything that exists is body, and that all change is motion. Sensation is motion in the organs caused by external bodies; imagination is decaying sense; thought is a train of imaginations. Reasoning is computation, the adding and subtracting of names. A science of politics should be built like geometry, from definitions.

Human nature. Voluntary action springs from appetite and aversion. Good and evil are names for what each person desires or shuns, and there is no highest good, only a restless desire of power after power that ceases only in death. People are roughly equal in ability, in that the weakest can kill the strongest.

The natural condition. Without a common power, equality, scarcity and mutual distrust produce a war of every man against every man. Competition, diffidence and glory are the causes. In that condition there is no industry, no arts, and no justice or injustice, since these depend on law. Every person has a right to everything, even to another's body.

Laws of nature and the covenant. Reason suggests articles of peace: seek peace where it can be had; lay down the right to all things if others will do the same; keep covenants. But covenants without the sword are only words. So each must agree with each to authorise one person or assembly to act for all. That person is the sovereign.

Sovereignty. The sovereign is not a party to the covenant and so cannot breach it. Sovereign power is undivided and includes judging doctrines and interpreting religion. Subjects keep only the liberty to defend their own lives. The obligation to obey lasts as long as the sovereign can protect.

Objections. Locke asked why anyone would exchange the danger of foxes for that of lions. Others have asked how people as distrustful as Hobbes describes could ever make the first covenant, and whether the laws of nature oblige as morality or only as prudence.

The geometry lesson. Aubrey's Brief Lives tells how Hobbes, at about forty, came upon Euclid open at a theorem, thought it impossible, and traced the proof back step by step until he was convinced. It made him in love with geometry. He resolved to give politics the same form: start from definitions, and derive conclusions that no one can deny who grants the definitions. Leviathan accordingly begins with sensation, speech and reason long before it reaches the commonwealth.

Why not a monster. Hobbes does not say that people are wicked. He says that in the absence of a common power, even moderate people must act aggressively, since they cannot know which of their neighbours is a threat, and the best defence is to strike first. He asks the reader to consider his own conduct: you lock your doors and chests, even with laws and officers to protect you. The argument is about a situation and not about character.

What the subject keeps. The covenant is among the subjects, not between subjects and sovereign, so the sovereign cannot breach it. But since the whole purpose is self-preservation, no one can be understood to have given up the right to resist those who come to kill, wound or imprison him. A subject may refuse to confess, and may refuse dangerous military service where a substitute can be found. And when the sovereign can no longer protect, the obligation of subjects ends.

Religion and reception. Half of Leviathan is about Scripture and the Church. Hobbes argues that the sovereign must decide which doctrines are publicly taught, since divided religious authority is a cause of civil war, and he interprets the Bible to remove any independent power of clergy. He was widely suspected of atheism; after the Great Fire of London, a parliamentary committee investigated his book. Modern game theory finds in his state of nature the structure of the prisoner's dilemma.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Whether Hobbes's laws of nature are genuine moral obligations, divine commands, or merely prudential advice is a long-standing dispute.

A common misreading

Hobbes did not hold that people are simply wicked. He argues that conflict arises among ordinary, even well-meaning people from competition, mutual distrust and the desire for reputation when no authority exists to enforce agreements.

Influenced by

Francis Bacon, Niccolò Machiavelli, Epicurus, William of Ockham

Influenced

Baruch Spinoza, John Locke, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, David Hume, John Rawls

Related ideas

Social contract, State of nature, Compatibilism

Schools and eras

Empiricism, Early Modern

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Thomas Hobbes in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.