Michel de Montaigne
French writer who invented the essay as a form for exploring his own mind, and revived ancient scepticism.
Life
Montaigne was raised on his family's estate near Bordeaux, where his father had him taught Latin as his first language. He served as a magistrate in Bordeaux, where he formed a celebrated friendship with Étienne de La Boétie. In 1571 he retired to his library in a tower of the château to write.
France was then torn by wars between Catholics and Protestants, and he acted at times as a mediator. He served two terms as mayor of Bordeaux, and kept revising and enlarging his book until he died.
Core ideas
- Human reason is weak, inconsistent and easily misled, and its claims to certainty are presumptuous.
- Customs differ so widely that we call “barbarous” simply what is not our own practice.
- By studying himself, an ordinary man, he studies the human condition.
- Cruelty is the worst of vices.
- His motto was the question “What do I know?”
In more depth
The essay. Montaigne invented a form. An essai is a trial or attempt, and his chapters test his judgement on whatever comes to hand: friendship, cannibals, thumbs, the fear of death. He revised by adding, never deleting, so the book records a mind changing over twenty years. I am myself the matter of my book, he tells the reader.
Scepticism. The longest chapter, the Apology for Raymond Sebond, draws on the newly published Sextus Empiricus to attack the pretensions of human reason. The senses deceive, philosophers contradict one another, customs vary without limit, and man has no good reason to rank himself above the animals. His motto was What do I know? The question form is deliberate: even I know nothing would assert too much.
What scepticism is for. The conclusion he draws is not despair. In religion, since reason cannot decide, one should keep to the inherited faith. In politics, change is more dangerous than the evils it aims to cure. In daily life, one should follow nature and custom with an easy mind.
Self-study. The later essays turn from books to experience. He describes his habits, illnesses and inconsistencies in detail, on the principle that each person bears the whole form of the human condition. The self he finds is not a fixed thing: we are all patchwork, and differ from ourselves as much as from others.
Cruelty and custom. In Of Cannibals he observes that everyone calls barbarous what is not their own practice, and judges European torture and religious war worse than the customs of the Brazilians. He names cruelty the worst of vices.
Influence. Descartes' method of doubt and Pascal's account of human weakness both answer Montaigne.
The tower. Montaigne was a magistrate at Bordeaux who retired in 1571, at thirty-eight, to the library in a tower of his family estate. He had sayings from Greek and Latin authors painted on the ceiling beams, many from Sextus Empiricus. He meant to rest and found his mind running loose, he says, like a runaway horse; he began to record its fancies to make it ashamed of itself. He later served two terms as mayor of Bordeaux during the Wars of Religion and was trusted by both sides.
On death. An early essay argues, with the Stoics, that to philosophise is to learn to die: keep death always in mind, and it loses its strangeness. The later essays change course. After a riding accident in which he was thought dead, he reports that the approach of death felt gentle. Peasants die well without preparation. Nature will teach you on the spot; do not trouble yourself. The shift is typical: experience corrects the books.
On experience. The last essay begins from the desire for knowledge and ends in the body. Laws, medicine and learned commentary multiply distinctions without reaching the particular case. He describes his own habits of eating, sleeping and illness, including his kidney stones, in detail. The conclusion: the finest lives are those that conform to the common human pattern, with order and without miracle; and on the loftiest throne in the world we are still sitting on our own rump.
The friendship and the method. His essay on friendship remembers Étienne de La Boétie, who died young: asked why he loved him, he can only answer, because it was he, because it was I. Montaigne revised the Essays in three main layers, adding to earlier passages without removing them, so that the book shows a mind changing over twenty years. He says he does not portray being but passing. That refusal to systematise is his philosophical position.
Works
- Essays, Books I–II, 1580
- Essays, Book III and revisions, 1588
- Essays, posthumous edition, 1595
Where scholars disagree
It is debated whether Montaigne remained a Pyrrhonian sceptic throughout or moved, in the later essays, toward a more confident trust in nature and experience.
A common misreading
The word “essay” did not yet name a literary genre. Montaigne's title, Essais, meant “attempts” or “trials” of his judgement.
Influenced by
Sextus Empiricus, Pyrrho, Seneca, Lucretius
Influenced
René Descartes, Blaise Pascal, Francis Bacon, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Friedrich Nietzsche
Schools and eras
Pyrrhonian Scepticism, Renaissance
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Michel de Montaigne in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.