G.W.F. Hegel
German idealist who presented reality and history as the self-development of reason, or spirit, toward freedom and self-knowledge.
Life
Hegel was born in Stuttgart and studied theology at Tübingen, where his friends included the poet Hölderlin and the philosopher Schelling. After years as a private tutor he taught at Jena, completing the Phenomenology of Spirit as Napoleon's army took the city in 1806. He then worked as a newspaper editor and as headmaster of a school in Nuremberg.
He was appointed professor at Heidelberg in 1816 and at Berlin in 1818, where he became the dominant philosopher in Germany. He died during a cholera epidemic in 1831. His lectures on history, art, religion and the history of philosophy were published by his students.
Core ideas
- Reality is the development of Geist (spirit or mind), which comes to know itself through nature, human history and culture.
- Thought advances dialectically: each position proves one-sided, turns into its opposite, and is taken up into a richer whole.
- World history is “the progress of the consciousness of freedom”.
- Self-consciousness depends on recognition by others, as in the struggle of master and servant.
- Freedom is realised in the institutions of ethical life: family, civil society and the state.
In more depth
The aim. Kant had separated what we know from what is. Hegel regards any such barrier as self-defeating: to draw a limit one must already be beyond it. Philosophy must show that thought and being are not finally opposed. The whole of reality is the self-development of what he calls spirit, or the Idea, and philosophy is its comprehension of itself. The true is the whole.
Dialectic. Hegel's method is not the application of a formula. He holds that each concept or form of life, examined on its own terms, turns out to contain a contradiction that drives it beyond itself. The result is a richer form that both cancels and preserves the earlier one; his word is aufheben. He did not describe this as thesis, antithesis and synthesis.
The Phenomenology. This book follows consciousness through a series of shapes, from bare sensory certainty to absolute knowing, each undone by its own standard. Its best-known episode is the struggle for recognition. Self-consciousness needs acknowledgement from another. The struggle ends with one becoming lord and the other bondsman. But the lord's recognition comes from someone he does not regard as an equal, while the bondsman, through work, shapes the world and comes to see himself in it.
The Logic. The Science of Logic develops the categories of thought from the emptiest, pure being, which turns out to be indistinguishable from nothing, and so passes into becoming. The sequence is meant to be the structure of reality itself and not only of our thinking.
History and the state. World history is the progress of the consciousness of freedom: in the ancient East one was free, in Greece and Rome some, in the modern world all. Freedom is realised in institutions, in the family, civil society and the state, which together make up ethical life. Individuals are free when they can recognise these institutions as the expression of their own rational will.
The rational and the actual. The preface to the Philosophy of Right says that what is rational is actual and what is actual is rational. Critics read this as a defence of the Prussian state. Defenders point out that actual in his usage means what fulfils its concept, not whatever exists.
After Hegel. His followers split. The Right read him as a Christian and conservative philosopher; the Left, including Feuerbach and Marx, turned his method against religion and the state. Kierkegaard objected that the system leaves no place for the existing individual.
Lord and bondsman. Self-consciousness, Hegel argues, exists only in being recognised by another. Two selves meet and each seeks to prove its independence by risking its life. One yields and becomes the bondsman. But the lord's victory is hollow, since recognition from someone he does not regard as an equal is worth little. The bondsman, working on things for the lord, shapes the world and sees himself in what he has made. The dependent consciousness turns out to hold the truth of independence. Marx and many later thinkers drew on the passage.
The owl of Minerva. Philosophy, the preface to the Philosophy of Right says, always comes too late to teach the world how it ought to be. It is its own time apprehended in thoughts. When philosophy paints its grey in grey, a shape of life has grown old; the owl of Minerva begins its flight only with the falling of dusk. The task is to understand what is, and to recognise reason as the rose in the cross of the present.
Ethical life. Hegel distinguishes abstract right, the sphere of property and contract; morality, the standpoint of the individual conscience; and ethical life, the institutions in which freedom is actual. Ethical life has three parts: the family, held together by love; civil society, the market in which each pursues private ends and which generates both wealth and a rabble of the poor; and the state, in which citizens will a common good. Freedom is being at home with oneself in these institutions.
What sublation means. Hegel's key term, aufheben, means at once to cancel, to preserve and to lift up. A one-sided position is not simply rejected. Its limitation is exposed, and what was true in it is kept as an element of a fuller view. He does not use the formula of thesis, antithesis and synthesis, which comes from other writers. The method is to follow each concept or form of life until its own standards show it to be inadequate.
Art, religion, philosophy. Absolute spirit knows itself in three forms: art presents the truth to the senses, religion in picture-thinking and story, philosophy in concepts. In his lectures on aesthetics Hegel said that art, in its highest vocation, is for us a thing of the past: it no longer satisfies our deepest need as it did the Greeks. The claim is often called the end of art thesis.
Works
- Phenomenology of Spirit, 1807
- Science of Logic, 1812–1816
- Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences, 1817
- Elements of the Philosophy of Right, 1820; title page dated 1821
Where scholars disagree
Interpreters divide between metaphysical readings, on which Hegel describes a cosmic spirit, and non-metaphysical readings, on which he continues Kant's inquiry into the conditions of thought. His politics have likewise been read as both authoritarian and liberal.
A common misreading
Hegel did not describe his method as “thesis, antithesis, synthesis”. The formula comes from Fichte and was attached to Hegel by later popularisers.
Influenced by
Immanuel Kant, Baruch Spinoza, Aristotle, Heraclitus, Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Influenced
Karl Marx, Søren Kierkegaard, John Dewey, Jean-Paul Sartre, Theodor W. Adorno, Jürgen Habermas, Nishida Kitarō
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open G.W.F. Hegel in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.