George Berkeley
Irish philosopher and bishop who denied the existence of matter, holding that to be is to be perceived.
Life
Berkeley was born near Kilkenny and educated at Trinity College Dublin, where he became a fellow. He published his main philosophical works before he was thirty. In 1728 he sailed to America to found a college in Bermuda, and lived in Rhode Island for nearly three years until it was clear the promised funds would not come.
In 1734 he became Bishop of Cloyne in the south of Ireland, where he spent almost twenty years. He died in Oxford.
Core ideas
- Esse est percipi: for sensible things, to exist is to be perceived.
- There is no material substance; reality consists of minds and their ideas.
- Locke's distinction between primary and secondary qualities fails, since both depend equally on the mind.
- There are no abstract general ideas.
- The order and persistence of the things we perceive are sustained by God.
In more depth
The target. Locke had said that we perceive ideas, some of which resemble qualities in material objects that cause them. Berkeley argues that this doctrine leads to scepticism, since we could never compare an idea with the object, and to atheism, since matter is supposed to exist independently of mind.
To be is to be perceived. A sensible thing, such as a cherry, is a collection of ideas: red, round, soft, sweet. Ideas exist only in being perceived. So sensible things exist only in being perceived. To suppose otherwise is to try to conceive something unconceived, which Berkeley thinks is contradictory. His critics say this confuses conceiving of a thing with the thing's being in a mind.
Against matter. An idea can be like nothing but an idea, so ideas cannot resemble unthinking things. Every argument showing that colour and taste depend on the perceiver applies equally to shape and motion, so the distinction between primary and secondary qualities collapses. And matter, as something inert that supports qualities, is a notion with no content.
Spirits and God. Besides ideas there are spirits, active beings that perceive and will. I produce some of my ideas, in imagination. The ideas of sense are not produced by me; they are more vivid, orderly and coherent. They must be caused by another spirit, and their order shows it to be wise and good. Sensible things continue to exist when no finite mind perceives them because God perceives them. The laws of nature are the regular ways in which God produces ideas in us.
Common sense. Berkeley insists that he denies nothing ordinary people believe. Tables and trees are exactly what we see and touch. What he denies is the philosophers' material substance.
Abstract ideas. He rejects Locke's doctrine that we form abstract general ideas, such as a triangle that is neither equilateral nor scalene. A general word works by a particular idea standing for others of its kind.
The new theory of vision. Berkeley's first book argues that distance is not seen. The eye receives light and colours only; that an object is far or near is suggested by cues such as the turn of the eyes and the faintness of the image, which experience has taught us to connect with what we would feel if we walked and touched. What is seen and what is touched are different things, linked by habit. The visible world is a language in which God tells us what tangible experience to expect.
Against the primary and secondary distinction. Locke allowed that colour, taste and warmth exist only as ideas in us, while shape, size and motion exist in bodies themselves. Berkeley replies that the arguments used for the first group apply to the second. Shape and size vary with the observer's position just as colour varies with light. And one cannot conceive an extended thing with no colour or texture at all. If the secondary qualities are in the mind, so are the primary.
Hylas and Philonous. The Three Dialogues restate the argument as a conversation. Hylas, whose name means matter, defends material substance; Philonous, lover of mind, drives him from one position to another: matter as what we perceive, as the cause of what we perceive, as an unknown support, as a mere something. In the end Hylas admits he can attach no meaning to the word. Philonous claims to have returned to common sense: the things we see and touch are the real things.
Science and God. Berkeley holds that natural science describes the order of our ideas and does not uncover hidden causes. Forces and attractions are mathematical devices for prediction. He criticised Newton's absolute space and, in The Analyst, the logic of the calculus, mocking vanishing quantities as ghosts of departed quantities. The steadiness of nature is God's constancy. He went to America hoping to found a college in Bermuda, and later became Bishop of Cloyne in Ireland.
Works
- An Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision, 1709
- A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge, 1710
- Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, 1713
A common misreading
Berkeley did not deny that tables and trees exist. He claimed to be defending common sense: such things are real and are exactly what we perceive, namely collections of ideas.
Influenced by
John Locke, René Descartes, William of Ockham
Influenced
David Hume, Immanuel Kant, Arthur Schopenhauer, John Stuart Mill
Schools and eras
Empiricism, Early Modern, Enlightenment
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open George Berkeley in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.