René Descartes
French philosopher and mathematician who sought a foundation for knowledge immune to doubt and argued that mind and body are distinct substances.
Life
Descartes was educated by the Jesuits at La Flèche and took a law degree before travelling and serving as a gentleman soldier. He later described a day of intense reflection and a night of vivid dreams in November 1619 as revealing his vocation. From 1628 he lived in the Dutch Republic, moving frequently and guarding his privacy.
He invented coordinate geometry and worked on optics and physics. On hearing of Galileo's condemnation in 1633 he withheld his own treatise on the world. In 1649 he accepted an invitation from Queen Christina of Sweden and died in Stockholm the following winter.
Core ideas
- Methodical doubt: set aside every belief that can be doubted, in order to find what cannot.
- The The Cogito: I cannot doubt that I exist while I am thinking.
- Whatever is clearly and distinctly perceived is true, a rule guaranteed by the existence of a God who does not deceive.
- Mind–body dualism: mind is a thinking, unextended substance; body is an extended, unthinking one.
- The physical world is to be explained mechanically, by size, shape and motion.
In more depth
The project. Descartes wants to establish something firm and lasting in the sciences. Finding that much of what he was taught was doubtful, he resolves to withhold assent from whatever is not completely certain and to rebuild from what survives.
The doubts. The senses sometimes deceive. More seriously, there are no sure signs to distinguish waking from dreaming, so any particular sensory belief may be false. Arithmetic and geometry seem to hold even in dreams, but a deceiver of the utmost power might make me go wrong even there. The doubt is a method, not a belief: he says no sane person ever seriously doubted these things.
The first certainty. However I am deceived, I must exist in order to be deceived. The proposition I am, I exist is true whenever I put it forward or conceive it. At this stage I know only that I am a thinking thing: something that doubts, understands, wills, imagines and senses.
God and the truth rule. I have an idea of an infinite and perfect being. A cause must have at least as much reality as its effect, and I, being finite, cannot be the source of that idea, so God exists. A perfect being is no deceiver, so what I perceive clearly and distinctly is true. Error arises because the will reaches further than the understanding and assents where perception is unclear. Critics in his own time charged that this reasons in a circle: clear and distinct perception is used to prove God, and God to guarantee clear and distinct perception.
Mind and body. I can clearly conceive myself as a thinking, unextended thing, and body as an extended, unthinking thing. What can be clearly conceived apart can exist apart, so mind and body are distinct substances. Yet they are closely joined, as sensations of pain and hunger show. Princess Elisabeth asked how something unextended can move a body. His replies, which appeal to a primitive notion of their union, did not satisfy her.
Nature. Matter is extension, and all its changes are to be explained mechanically by size, shape and motion. Animals are machines. This programme, more than the metaphysics, shaped seventeenth-century science.
The stove-heated room. Descartes dates his project to November 1619, when, a young soldier in Germany, he spent a day shut in a heated room and resolved to rebuild knowledge on his own foundations. He compares the sciences to a city grown haphazardly, less well ordered than one laid out by a single engineer. The Discourse gives four rules: accept only what is evident; divide each difficulty into parts; proceed from the simple to the complex; make reviews so complete that nothing is omitted.
The wax. In the Second Meditation he takes a piece of wax fresh from the hive. It has taste, scent, colour, shape, and gives a sound when struck. Brought near the fire, every one of these changes, yet it is the same wax. What I know as the wax is therefore not given by the senses or the imagination, which could not run through the endless shapes it might take. It is grasped by the mind alone, as something extended, flexible and changeable.
The source of error. If God is no deceiver, why do I err? The Fourth Meditation answers that judgement requires both intellect, which is limited, and will, which is unlimited. Error arises when I let the will affirm what the intellect does not clearly perceive. It is a misuse of my freedom and not a defect in my nature, and I can avoid it by withholding assent. The account is at once a theodicy and a method.
Animals, passions and Elisabeth. Descartes held that animal behaviour can be explained mechanically and that language and flexible reasoning mark out the possession of a mind. In reply to Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia, who pressed him on how mind and body interact, he came to speak of their union as a third primitive notion, known best by ordinary life. Their correspondence led to his last book, The Passions of the Soul. He died in Stockholm in 1650, having gone there to teach Queen Christina.
In their words
I think, therefore I am.
Works
- Discourse on the Method, 1637
- Meditations on First Philosophy, 1641
- Principles of Philosophy, 1644
- The Passions of the Soul, 1649
Where scholars disagree
Critics from Descartes's own day onward have charged that he argues in a circle, using clear and distinct perception to prove God and God to guarantee clear and distinct perception. Whether he escapes the “Cartesian Circle” is still debated.
A common misreading
The Meditations do not contain the words “I think, therefore I am”. That formula comes from the Discourse and the Principles. In the Second Meditation the conclusion is that “I am, I exist” is true whenever I state or conceive it.
Influenced by
Augustine of Hippo, Anselm of Canterbury, Michel de Montaigne, Sextus Empiricus
Influenced
Baruch Spinoza, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, John Locke, Blaise Pascal, Immanuel Kant, Edmund Husserl
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open René Descartes in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.