Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz

1646 CE – 1716 CE · Leipzig and Hanover, Germany · European

German polymath who invented the calculus independently of Newton and held that the world consists of simple, mind-like substances in pre-established harmony.

Life

Leibniz was born in Leipzig, the son of a professor, and took a doctorate in law. A diplomatic mission brought him to Paris from 1672 to 1676, where he mastered the new mathematics and developed the differential and integral calculus. From 1676 he served the dukes of Hanover as counsellor, librarian and historian.

He worked on logic, physics, engineering, law, theology and the reunion of the churches, and corresponded with more than a thousand people. His last years were embittered by the dispute with Newton's followers over priority for the calculus. Much of his philosophy is found in letters and short papers.

Core ideas

In more depth

Two principles. All reasoning rests on two principles. By the principle of contradiction, whatever involves a contradiction is false. By the principle of sufficient reason, nothing is so without a reason why it is so and not otherwise. From these come two kinds of truth: truths of reason, which are necessary, and truths of fact, which are contingent.

Substance. In every true statement the concept of the predicate is contained in that of the subject. So the complete concept of an individual contains everything that will ever be true of it. Whether this leaves room for contingency and freedom was the objection Arnauld raised at once. Leibniz replied that the reasons incline without necessitating, since showing the connection would take an infinite analysis.

Monads. Real substances must be true unities, and nothing extended is, since it can be divided. The basic constituents of reality are therefore simple, unextended substances, the monads. Each has perceptions and an inner drive from one perception to the next. Monads have no windows: nothing comes in or goes out. Each mirrors the whole universe from its own point of view, with varying degrees of clarity. Bodies are well-founded appearances of collections of monads.

Pre-established harmony. Since substances do not act on each other, their agreement was set up by God at creation, like clocks made so well that they keep time together. This also explains the correspondence of mind and body.

The best possible world. God surveys all possible worlds and, being perfectly wise and good, creates the best, the one that combines the greatest variety with the simplest laws. Evil is permitted because any world without it would be worse overall. Voltaire's Candide mocked the claim, though Leibniz never said that everything in this world is good.

Against Locke and Newton. The mind is not a blank tablet but a block of marble with veins that predispose it to a figure. Space and time are not containers, as Newton held, but systems of relations among things.

A scattered genius. Leibniz spent his career as counsellor and librarian to the dukes of Hanover, charged among other things with writing the history of their house. He invented the calculus independently of Newton and devised the notation still in use, built a calculating machine, worked on binary arithmetic, mining engineering and the reunion of the churches. He published one philosophical book in his lifetime, the Theodicy. His philosophy has to be assembled from short essays and thousands of letters.

The complete concept. In the Discourse on Metaphysics Leibniz holds that in every true statement the predicate is contained in the concept of the subject. The concept of an individual, such as Alexander or Caesar, therefore contains everything that will ever be true of him. Arnauld objected that this makes every event in a life necessary. Leibniz replied by distinguishing truths whose denial is a contradiction from truths that depend on God's free choice of the best, where the analysis runs to infinity.

The identity of indiscernibles. No two things in nature are exactly alike, differing only in number. If they were, God would have no reason to place one here and the other there, and nothing happens without a reason. Leibniz tells of a gentleman at court who thought he could find two identical leaves and searched the garden in vain. He uses the principle against atoms and against absolute space: a universe moved three feet to the east would differ in nothing discernible, so it would not be a different state.

The mill. Imagine a machine built to think, feel and perceive, enlarged so that one could walk into it as into a mill. Inside one would find only parts pushing one another, and never anything to explain a perception. So perception must be sought in a simple substance and not in a composite or a machine. The argument is an early statement of what is now called the explanatory gap between physical processes and experience.

The universal characteristic. Leibniz hoped for an alphabet of human thought, in which complex ideas would be combinations of simple ones, and a calculus for reasoning with them. Disputes could then be settled by sitting down and saying: let us calculate. The project was not realised, but it anticipates symbolic logic, and his notes on logic were rediscovered when Frege and Russell had done the work again.

Works

A common misreading

“The best of all possible worlds” does not mean that everything in the world is good. Leibniz's claim is that no other possible world, taken as a whole, would have been better.

Influenced by

René Descartes, Baruch Spinoza, Aristotle, Moses Maimonides

Influenced

Immanuel Kant, David Hume, Bertrand Russell, Gottlob Frege, David Lewis

Related ideas

Principle of sufficient reason, Possible worlds

Schools and eras

Rationalism, Early Modern, Enlightenment

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.