Baruch Spinoza
Dutch philosopher of Portuguese-Jewish descent who identified God with nature and derived an ethics of freedom through understanding.
Life
Spinoza was born into the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam. In 1656, aged twenty-three, he was expelled from it by a decree of unusual severity; the specific charges are not recorded. He afterwards lived quietly in several Dutch towns, supporting himself in part by grinding lenses.
He published one work under his name, on Descartes, and the Theological-Political Treatise anonymously in 1670; it was soon banned. In 1673 he declined a professorship at Heidelberg to protect his freedom to philosophise. The Ethics appeared just after his death.
Core ideas
- There is only one substance, “God or Nature”, and everything else is a mode of it.
- Thought and extension are two attributes of the one substance, so mind and body are the same thing under two descriptions.
- Everything follows necessarily from the nature of God; there is no free will in the sense of uncaused choice.
- Each thing strives to persevere in its being (conatus), and the emotions are to be understood like any other natural phenomenon.
- Freedom and blessedness come from understanding the causes of things, culminating in the “intellectual love of God”.
In more depth
One substance. A substance is what exists in itself and is conceived through itself. Spinoza argues that there can be only one such thing, that it necessarily exists, and that it is absolutely infinite. He calls it God or Nature. Everything else, including every body and every mind, is a mode of it, a way in which the one substance exists. God is not a creator standing outside the world, and does not act for purposes.
Mind and body. Thought and extension are two attributes of the one substance, two ways in which the same reality is expressed. A human mind and its body are one and the same thing conceived under different attributes. So mind does not move body or body mind, and the problem of their interaction that troubled Descartes does not arise. The order of ideas is the same as the order of things.
Necessity. Everything follows from the divine nature with the same necessity as the properties of a triangle follow from its definition. Nothing is contingent. People believe themselves free because they are aware of their desires and ignorant of the causes that determine them.
The affects. Each thing strives to persist in its being; this striving is its essence. Joy is the passage to greater power of acting, sadness to less. The other emotions are these combined with ideas of their causes. We are passive, in bondage, when moved by external causes we do not understand.
Freedom and blessedness. Freedom is not uncaused choice. It is acting from one's own nature with adequate understanding. An emotion ceases to be a passion once we form a clear idea of it. The highest state is the intellectual love of God, the joy that accompanies understanding things as they follow from the eternal nature of God.
Religion and politics. The Theological-Political Treatise reads the Bible as a historical document written for the understanding of ordinary people, whose aim is obedience and not truth, and argues that the purpose of the state is freedom, including freedom to philosophise.
Reception. He was denounced as an atheist for a century and then taken up by the German Romantics as a philosopher intoxicated with God. Whether his God is more than nature under another name is still argued.
The geometrical order. The Ethics is set out like Euclid: definitions, axioms, numbered propositions with demonstrations, and scholia, in which Spinoza speaks more freely. The form is a statement about its content. If everything follows from the nature of God with the same necessity with which the properties of a triangle follow from its definition, then the true account of reality will be a deduction. A reader does well to begin with the scholia and the appendix to Part I, which attacks belief in purposes in nature.
The opening argument. A substance is what is in itself and conceived through itself. Two substances with nothing in common could not affect each other, and two substances could not share an attribute, since then nothing would distinguish them. A substance cannot be produced by another, so it exists by its own nature. God is defined as a substance with infinite attributes. Since God exists and has every attribute, no other substance can exist. Whatever is, is in God.
Conatus. Each thing, so far as it is in itself, strives to persevere in its being. In human beings this striving, when we are conscious of it, is desire. Joy is the passage to greater power of acting, sadness the passage to less. All other emotions are built from these three together with ideas of their causes: love is joy with the idea of an external cause, hatred is sadness with one. We do not desire things because we judge them good; we judge them good because we desire them.
Three kinds of knowledge. The first is opinion or imagination, drawn from random experience and hearsay, and is the only source of falsity. The second is reason, which grasps what things have in common. The third is intuitive knowledge, which proceeds from an adequate idea of God's attributes to the essence of particular things. Passions are confused ideas, and an emotion that is a passion ceases to be one as soon as we form a clear idea of it. Understanding is therefore the route to freedom.
The excommunication. In 1656 the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam expelled Spinoza, aged twenty-three, with an unusually severe formula, for reasons the document does not specify. He lived afterwards as a lens grinder, declined a chair at Heidelberg to keep his freedom, and published under his own name only an exposition of Descartes. The Ethics appeared after his death in 1677.
Works
- Principles of Cartesian Philosophy, 1663
- Theological-Political Treatise, 1670
- Ethics, published posthumously, 1677
- Political Treatise (unfinished), 1677
Where scholars disagree
Whether Spinoza is best described as a pantheist, an atheist or something else has been argued since the eighteenth century.
A common misreading
Spinoza was denounced for generations as an atheist, yet God is the central concept of his system. What he denied was a personal God who creates by choice, performs miracles and issues commands.
Influenced by
René Descartes, Thomas Hobbes, Moses Maimonides, Niccolò Machiavelli
Influenced
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, G.W.F. Hegel, Friedrich Nietzsche, Gilles Deleuze
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Baruch Spinoza in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.