Sextus Empiricus
Physician and sceptic whose writings are the main surviving source for ancient Pyrrhonism.
Life
Almost nothing is known about Sextus. He was a physician, probably active around 200 CE, and his name links him to the Empiric school of medicine. Where he lived and taught is unknown.
His works are the only complete texts to survive from the ancient sceptical tradition. Their rediscovery and Latin translation in the 1560s set off a sceptical crisis in early modern Europe.
Core ideas
- Scepticism is an ability to set opposing arguments against one another, so that they appear equally strong.
- This equal balance leads to suspension of judgement (epochē), and tranquillity follows unexpectedly.
- The sceptic lives by appearances, custom and natural impulse, without affirming that things really are as they seem.
- The Five Modes: any attempted proof ends in disagreement, infinite regress, relativity, arbitrary assumption or circularity.
In more depth
Scepticism as an ability. Sextus defines scepticism as an ability to set appearances and thoughts against one another in any way whatever. Because the opposed accounts are equally strong, the inquirer comes to suspension of judgement, and after that to tranquillity. The sceptic began by hoping to find the truth and so gain peace; unable to decide, he suspended judgement, and peace followed unexpectedly, as a shadow follows a body.
The modes. The sceptic's tools are standard patterns of argument. The Ten Modes collect conflicts of appearance: between animals, between people, between the senses, across circumstances, positions and customs. The Five Modes are more general. Any claim offered as true meets disagreement; a reason given for it needs a further reason, and so on without end; or the reasoning runs in a circle; or it stops at a bare assumption; and everything is relative to the judge. Together they are meant to block every attempt at justification.
Living by appearances. The old objection is that someone without beliefs cannot act. Sextus replies that the sceptic follows appearances without asserting that they are true. He is guided by nature, by the compulsion of feelings such as hunger, by the laws and customs of his country, and by the skills he has been taught. What exactly the sceptic lacks, all beliefs or only theoretical beliefs about the real nature of things, is the main question among modern scholars.
Not a doctrine. The sceptic does not assert that knowledge is impossible. That would be a dogmatic claim, which Sextus attributes to the Academics. His own sayings report only how things seem to him now, and he compares sceptical arguments to a purgative that carries itself out along with the disease.
Influence. The rediscovery of Sextus in the sixteenth century supplied Montaigne and then Descartes with the sceptical arguments that set the agenda for early modern theory of knowledge.
How a sceptic becomes one. Sextus tells the story as a kind of accident. The future sceptic sets out to decide which appearances are true, in order to be tranquil. Finding the arguments on each side of equal weight, he cannot decide and suspends judgement. Tranquillity then follows unexpectedly. He compares the painter Apelles, who, despairing of painting the foam on a horse's mouth, threw his sponge at the picture, and the mark it left produced the effect he wanted.
Agrippa's trilemma. Among the Five Modes, three work together. Ask anyone for the ground of a claim. Either they give a further ground, and then a ground for that, without end; or they stop at something they simply assume; or they eventually rest a claim on something that itself rests on the claim. Infinite regress, bare assumption and circularity seem to exhaust the options. The argument is still the standard starting point for theories of justification.
The fourfold guide. A sceptic does not stay in bed. Sextus names four things the sceptic follows without holding any belief: the guidance of nature, by which we perceive and think; the compulsion of feelings, by which hunger leads to food; the handing down of laws and customs; and the teaching of crafts. Sextus was himself a physician, and the medical school he is associated with treated patients by experience of what works, without theories of hidden causes.
What is and is not suspended. Sextus says the sceptic does not dispute that honey appears sweet; the question is whether it is sweet in its nature. Scholars disagree about how far this goes. On one reading the sceptic gives up only theoretical beliefs of the kind philosophers and scientists hold, and keeps everyday beliefs. On another he gives up all belief and lives by appearances alone. The texts support both, and the dispute bears on whether such a life is possible.
Works
- Outlines of Pyrrhonism, c. 200 CE
- Against the Mathematicians (Against the Professors), c. 200 CE
A common misreading
The Pyrrhonist does not assert that knowledge is impossible. Sextus treats that as a dogmatic claim in its own right; the sceptic neither affirms nor denies it and keeps inquiring.
Influenced by
Influenced
Michel de Montaigne, René Descartes, David Hume
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Pyrrhonian Scepticism, Hellenistic and Roman
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Sextus Empiricus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.