Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Anselm of Canterbury

1033 CE – 1109 CE · Aosta, Italy; Bec, Normandy; Canterbury, England · European

Benedictine monk and archbishop who devised the ontological argument for the existence of God.

Also known as: St Anselm

Life

Anselm was born in Aosta in the Alps and entered the Norman monastery of Bec, where he became prior and then abbot. He wrote his main philosophical works there, at the request of fellow monks who wanted arguments that did not rely on the authority of Scripture.

In 1093 he became Archbishop of Canterbury. His later years were taken up by conflicts with two English kings over the independence of the Church, and he was twice exiled.

Core ideas

In more depth

Faith seeking understanding. Anselm does not argue in order to reach belief. He believes, and then asks reason to show why what he believes must be so, without appeal to Scripture. His phrase for this was faith seeking understanding.

The Proslogion argument. God is that than which nothing greater can be conceived. Even the fool who says there is no God understands this phrase, so such a being exists at least in his understanding. But what exists in reality as well is greater than what exists in the understanding alone. So if it existed only in the understanding, something greater could be conceived, which contradicts the definition. Therefore it exists in reality. A second argument in the next chapter holds that such a being cannot even be thought not to exist.

Gaunilo's reply. The monk Gaunilo answered on behalf of the fool that by the same reasoning one could prove the existence of a lost island more excellent than any other. Anselm replied that the argument works only for that than which nothing greater can be conceived, since an island, however good, can always be conceived to be better or not to exist.

Later criticism. Aquinas rejected the argument on the ground that we do not grasp God's essence well enough for his existence to be self-evident to us. Kant's objection is the best known: existence is not a property that adds to the concept of a thing, so a being is not made greater by having it. Modern defenders have recast the argument in terms of necessary existence, which is closer to Anselm's second version.

Other work. The Monologion argues from degrees of goodness in things to a supreme good through which they are good. Why God Became Man argues that human sin incurs a debt of honour that only a being both divine and human could repay, a theory of atonement that shaped Western theology.

The second argument. Proslogion 3 argues differently from chapter 2. It is possible to think of a being that cannot be thought not to exist, and such a being is greater than one that can be thought not to exist. So if that than which nothing greater can be thought could be thought not to exist, it would not be what it is. Therefore it exists so truly that it cannot even be thought not to exist. Twentieth-century defenders, including Hartshorne, Malcolm and Plantinga, took this as the stronger argument.

How the fool can say it. If God cannot be thought not to exist, how did the fool say in his heart that there is no God? Anselm distinguishes two ways of thinking a thing: thinking the word that signifies it, and understanding the thing itself. In the first way one can say anything. In the second, no one who understands what God is can think that he is not. The distinction answers the objection and also shows what the argument is meant to do: lead the mind from words to understanding.

Truth, rightness and freedom. In three connected dialogues Anselm defines truth as rightness perceptible by the mind alone, justice as rightness of will kept for its own sake, and free choice as the power to keep that rightness. Freedom is therefore not the ability to sin or not to sin. God and the blessed cannot sin and are more free, not less. The definition places freedom in a positive capacity and not in an open choice between alternatives.

The setting. Anselm was born at Aosta, in what is now northern Italy, and became a monk and then abbot at Bec in Normandy, where the works were written at the request of his monks, who asked for arguments that did not rest on the authority of Scripture. As Archbishop of Canterbury from 1093 he spent years in conflict with two English kings over the rights of the Church and went twice into exile. He called his method faith seeking understanding, a phrase that served as the motto of scholastic theology.

Works

A common misreading

Anselm did not call his proof the “ontological argument”. The name was given by Immanuel Kant, some seven hundred years later, to arguments of this type.

Influenced by

Augustine of Hippo, Boethius

Influenced

Thomas Aquinas, John Duns Scotus, René Descartes

Related ideas

Ontological argument

Schools and eras

Scholasticism, Medieval

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Anselm of Canterbury in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.