Thomas Reid
Scottish philosopher of common sense, who rejected the theory of ideas that led from Locke to Hume's scepticism.
Life
Reid was a Presbyterian minister for fifteen years before becoming a professor at Aberdeen, where he helped found a philosophical society that discussed David Hume's work. In 1764 he succeeded Adam Smith in the chair of moral philosophy at Glasgow. He sent Hume the manuscript of his first book through a friend, and their exchange was courteous.
Core ideas
- The theory that we perceive only ideas in our own minds is a hypothesis without evidence, and the source of scepticism.
- Perception is of external things themselves and carries an immediate belief in their existence.
- Principles of common sense are the foundation of all reasoning and cannot be proved.
- Human beings have active power: they are the causes of their own free actions.
- Personal identity is simple and cannot be reduced to memory.
In more depth
The way of ideas. From Descartes to Hume, philosophers assumed that what the mind directly perceives is always an idea or impression within itself. John Locke thought ideas represent outer things; George Berkeley concluded there are no outer things; Hume concluded that there is neither matter nor a self. Reid says that he once accepted the assumption and that Hume's Treatise woke him. If a theory leads by valid steps to conclusions no one can believe, the fault is in the premise. And there is no evidence for it: ideas, as intermediate objects, are a philosopher's fiction.
Common sense. Some beliefs are held by all people as part of their natural constitution: that the things I distinctly perceive exist, that I am the same person as yesterday, that other people have minds, that what will happen will resemble what has happened. They cannot be proved, since any proof would rest on premises less certain. Nor need they be. To trust reason while distrusting the senses is arbitrary, since both came from the same shop. A philosopher who denies them in his study relies on them when he leaves it.
Sensation and perception. Reid distinguishes the sensation, a feeling in the mind such as the smell of a rose, from the perception of the quality in the object that causes it. Sensations are natural signs. The mind passes from them to their objects by an original principle of its constitution, as we pass from a facial expression to a feeling, without reasoning. Against John Locke on identity he gave the case of the brave officer. Against determinism he argued that we have a notion of cause only from our own power to act.
Works
- An Inquiry into the Human Mind on the Principles of Common Sense, 1764
- Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man, 1785
- Essays on the Active Powers of Man, 1788
Influenced by
David Hume, John Locke, George Berkeley, Francis Bacon
Influenced
G.E. Moore, Charles Sanders Peirce
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Thomas Reid in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.