Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Adam Smith

1723 CE – 1790 CE · Kirkcaldy, Glasgow and Edinburgh, Scotland · European

Scottish moral philosopher who grounded ethics in sympathy and founded modern economics with The Wealth of Nations.

Life

Smith was born in Kirkcaldy and studied at Glasgow and Oxford. In 1752 he became professor of moral philosophy at Glasgow, where he wrote The Theory of Moral Sentiments. He was a close friend of David Hume.

He resigned in 1764 to travel in France as tutor to a young duke, meeting leading French economists. He then spent ten years writing The Wealth of Nations, published in 1776. He ended his career as a commissioner of customs in Edinburgh and had most of his unpublished papers burned before he died.

Core ideas

In more depth

Sympathy. The Theory of Moral Sentiments begins from the observation that we are interested in the fortunes of others. Because we cannot feel what another feels, we imagine ourselves in their situation. When the feelings we imagine match the ones they show, we approve of theirs as proper. Moral judgement arises from this imaginative exchange of positions.

The impartial spectator. We learn to judge ourselves by seeing how others respond to us, as in a mirror. Gradually we form the idea of a well-informed and impartial spectator and judge our own conduct by what such a person would approve. This is conscience. It allows us to desire being worthy of praise and not merely being praised, and to correct the partiality of self-love.

The division of labour. The Wealth of Nations opens with the pin factory, where ten workers dividing eighteen operations make many thousands of pins a day. The division of labour is the chief cause of rising productivity. It follows from the human propensity to exchange and is limited by the extent of the market. We expect our dinner from the butcher and baker's regard to their own interest, not from their benevolence.

Markets and their limits. Where there is competition, prices tend toward their natural level and resources flow to where they are most wanted, so that individuals pursuing their own gain are often led to promote an end they did not intend. The famous phrase about an invisible hand occurs once in the book. Smith attacked the mercantile system of monopolies and trade restrictions. He also assigned the state justice, defence, public works and education, warned that merchants combine against the public, and described how repetitive work stunts the worker.

One author or two. Nineteenth-century scholars thought the book on sympathy and the book on self-interest contradicted each other. Most now read them as parts of one project: commerce operates within a framework of justice and moral sentiment.

A Glasgow professor. Smith held the chair of moral philosophy at Glasgow and lectured on theology, ethics, jurisprudence and political economy as parts of one course. He left to travel in France as tutor to a young duke, where he met the physiocrats, and spent ten years at home in Kirkcaldy writing the Wealth of Nations. He had his unpublished papers burned before his death. Hume was his closest friend, and Smith's account of Hume's calm death caused him more abuse, he said, than his attack on the commercial system.

The butcher and the baker. It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest. The passage does not say that people are only selfish. It says that in a large society each person needs the help of multitudes he will never know, and cannot win it by friendship. Exchange lets strangers serve one another. The same book says the rich are led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of their intention.

The poor man's son. The Theory of Moral Sentiments tells of a poor man's son whom heaven has visited with ambition. He admires the ease of the rich, toils all his life to reach it, and in old age finds that wealth and greatness are mere trinkets, no better for comfort of body or peace of mind than a tweezers-case. Yet it is well that nature deceives us so: this deception keeps in motion the industry of mankind. Smith holds both judgements at once.

What the state must do. Smith assigns the sovereign three duties: defence, the administration of justice, and public works and institutions that no individual could profit by providing. Among the last he includes the education of the common people, to counter the mental damage done by the division of labour, which confines a worker to a few simple operations. He warned that merchants seldom meet without the conversation ending in a conspiracy against the public.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Nineteenth-century German scholars saw a contradiction between the sympathy of the first book and the self-interest of the second (“the Adam Smith problem”). Most scholars now regard the two as consistent.

A common misreading

The “invisible hand” is often presented as the core of his thought. The phrase occurs once in The Wealth of Nations and once in The Theory of Moral Sentiments, and Smith was sharply critical of merchants' influence on policy.

Influenced by

David Hume, Montesquieu, Epictetus

Influenced

Karl Marx, John Stuart Mill, G.W.F. Hegel

Schools and eras

Enlightenment

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Adam Smith in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.