Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Edmund Burke

1729 CE – 1797 CE · Dublin, Ireland; London, England · European

Irish-born statesman whose critique of the French Revolution became the founding text of modern conservatism.

Life

Burke was born in Dublin to a Protestant father and a Catholic mother and studied at Trinity College before moving to London. He first became known for an essay on aesthetics. From 1765 he sat in the House of Commons for nearly thirty years as a leading Whig.

He argued for conciliation with the American colonies, for relief of Irish Catholics, and for the impeachment of Warren Hastings over misrule in India. In 1790 he denounced the French Revolution, predicting that it would end in terror and military dictatorship.

Core ideas

In more depth

Against abstraction. Burke's Reflections is a letter attacking the French Revolution in its first year. His complaint is that the revolutionaries tried to rebuild a society from general principles, the rights of man, as if it were a blank sheet. Circumstances, he says, give every political principle its colour and effect. Government is a practical art that requires experience, more than any one person can gain in a lifetime.

Prejudice and prescription. He defends prejudice, meaning the inherited judgements people act on without reasoning them out. The individual's stock of reason is small, and individuals do better to draw on the general bank and capital of nations and ages. Institutions that have lasted have a presumption in their favour, since they embody the adjustments of many generations.

The partnership of generations. Society is a contract, but not one to be dissolved at pleasure like a trading agreement. It is a partnership in all science, art and virtue, between those who are living, those who are dead and those who are to be born. The present generation holds its institutions in trust.

Reform. Burke was not opposed to change. A state without the means of some change is without the means of its conservation. But reform should repair the existing structure, not demolish it. He had supported the American colonists, Irish Catholics and the prosecution of misrule in India, and saw no inconsistency: in each case he defended established rights against arbitrary power.

Objections. Paine replied that Burke pitied the plumage and forgot the dying bird, and that no generation can bind the next. Wollstonecraft charged him with defending inherited privilege. He predicted that the Revolution would end in military rule.

The sublime. His early treatise on aesthetics distinguishes the beautiful, linked to pleasure and smallness, from the sublime, linked to terror experienced at a safe distance.

The politician. Burke was an Irishman who made his career in the English House of Commons as the leading mind of the Rockingham Whigs. He was never in high office. His speeches were long and he was nicknamed the dinner bell for emptying the chamber, but they were read. The Reflections began as a reply to a sermon by the dissenting minister Richard Price, who had congratulated the French National Assembly and claimed for the English the right to choose their own governors.

The speech to the electors of Bristol. In 1774 Burke told his new constituents what a representative owes them. He owes his attention and his labour; but he also owes them his judgement, and he betrays them if he sacrifices it to their opinion. Parliament is not a congress of ambassadors from hostile interests but a deliberative assembly of one nation. The speech is the standard statement of the trustee view of representation against the view that a member is a delegate bound by instructions.

America and India. Burke urged conciliation with the American colonies on grounds of prudence: the question is not whether you have a right to make your people miserable, but whether it is not your interest to make them happy. For years he led the impeachment of Warren Hastings, governor-general in Bengal, charging the East India Company with plunder and insisting that the same moral law binds Englishmen in Asia as at home. These campaigns show that his defence of inherited order was not a defence of power as such.

The queen and the age of chivalry. The most famous passage of the Reflections recalls Marie Antoinette as he saw her at Versailles and laments that ten thousand swords did not leap from their scabbards to avenge an insult to her: the age of chivalry is gone; that of sophisters, economists and calculators has succeeded. Critics found it theatrical. Its argument is that power is made gentle by sentiment and manners, the “decent drapery of life”, and that stripping these away leaves only force.

Works

A common misreading

“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing” has not been found anywhere in Burke's writings or speeches.

Influenced by

Montesquieu, David Hume, Cicero, Aristotle

Influenced

Immanuel Kant, Mary Wollstonecraft, G.W.F. Hegel

Schools and eras

Enlightenment

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Edmund Burke in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.