Auguste Comte
French founder of positivism, who held that knowledge is limited to observable phenomena and their laws, and who named the science of sociology.
Life
Comte studied at the École Polytechnique in Paris and worked for several years as secretary to the social reformer Saint-Simon, with whom he later broke. He never held a regular academic post and lived by teaching mathematics and on the support of admirers, among them John Stuart Mill.
He delivered and published his Course of Positive Philosophy over twelve years. In later life he founded a “Religion of Humanity”, with its own calendar and rites, which cost him many followers.
Core ideas
- The law of three stages: human thought passes from the theological, through the metaphysical, to the positive or scientific stage.
- Positive knowledge gives up the search for ultimate causes and seeks only the laws relating observable phenomena.
- The sciences form a hierarchy from mathematics to sociology, each depending on those before it.
- Society should be reorganised on scientific principles.
- He coined the words “sociology” and “altruism”.
In more depth
The law of three stages. Comte holds that each branch of knowledge, and the human mind as a whole, passes through three stages. In the theological stage phenomena are explained by the will of gods. In the metaphysical stage gods are replaced by abstract forces and essences. In the positive stage the search for ultimate causes is given up, and the mind confines itself to discovering the laws that connect phenomena, by observation and reasoning.
The order of the sciences. The sciences reach the positive stage in a fixed order, from the most general and simple to the most complex: mathematics, astronomy, physics, chemistry, biology, and finally the science of society. Each depends on those before it but cannot be reduced to them. He denied that psychology based on introspection could be a science.
Sociology. Comte coined the word sociology for the last science. Social statics studies the conditions of order, how the parts of a society fit together. Social dynamics studies the laws of progress, of which the three stages is the chief. Knowledge of these laws would allow prediction and so rational reform. His motto was order and progress.
The Religion of Humanity. In his later work Comte concluded that society needs a spiritual power and a shared object of devotion. He designed a religion without God, with Humanity as the Great Being, a calendar of secular saints, sacraments and a priesthood of scientists. He coined the word altruism for its ethic of living for others.
Reception. Mill admired the earlier philosophy of science and deplored the later religion as a blueprint for spiritual despotism. The claim that the metaphysical is a stage to be outgrown was taken up, in a different form, by the logical positivists. His historical law is now regarded as far too simple.
The life. Comte was a brilliant student at the École Polytechnique and then secretary to the social reformer Saint-Simon, with whom he quarrelled. He gave his Course of Positive Philosophy as private lectures, suffered a mental breakdown in 1826, and never obtained a secure academic post. In 1844 he met Clotilde de Vaux, who died two years later. Her memory inspired the turn in his later work toward feeling: he placed love above intellect, with the motto “live for others”.
What positive means. A positive science gives up the search for first causes and final purposes. It observes phenomena and finds the invariable relations of succession and resemblance among them, which are their laws. The point of knowing laws is prediction and therefore action: from science comes foresight, from foresight comes action. Comte did not hold that science is a bare collection of facts. No observation is possible, he says, without a theory to direct it.
Statics and dynamics. Sociology has two parts. Social statics studies order: the conditions of existence common to all societies, such as the family, the division of labour and government, and their mutual dependence. Social dynamics studies progress: the necessary stages of development. Order and progress are the two aspects of every healthy society. The motto appears on the flag of Brazil, where positivism had many followers among the founders of the republic.
Against psychology and for history. Comte denied that the mind can observe itself, since the observer and the observed would be the same organ, and so he left psychology out of his list of sciences, dividing its matter between biology and sociology. He held that no idea can be understood except through its history. Mill admired the Course and was dismayed by the later system, which he described as the most complete spiritual and temporal despotism ever to come from a human brain.
Works
- Course of Positive Philosophy, 1830–1842
- A General View of Positivism, 1848
- System of Positive Polity, 1851–1854
A common misreading
Comte's positivism is not the same as twentieth-century Logical Positivism. The later movement shared his hostility to metaphysics but rested on modern logic and a theory of meaning that he did not hold.
Influenced by
Francis Bacon, David Hume, Montesquieu
Influenced
John Stuart Mill, Rudolf Carnap
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Auguste Comte in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.