Søren Kierkegaard
Danish religious thinker who insisted on the single individual's passionate choice against the abstractions of system and crowd.
Life
Kierkegaard spent almost his whole life in Copenhagen, living on an inheritance from his stern and devout father. In 1841 he broke off his engagement to Regine Olsen, a decision he reflected on in his writings for years.
Between 1843 and 1850 he produced a remarkable series of books, many under pseudonyms representing points of view that are not simply his own. In his last year he launched a fierce public attack on the Danish state church. He collapsed in the street and died at forty-two.
Core ideas
- Truth that matters for existence must be appropriated inwardly; in this sense “subjectivity is truth”.
- There are different spheres of existence: the aesthetic, the ethical and the religious.
- Faith is not the conclusion of an argument but a commitment made in the face of objective uncertainty (see Leap of faith).
- Anxiety is the dizziness of freedom, and despair is a failure to be oneself.
- Against G.W.F. Hegel, an existing individual cannot be absorbed into a system.
In more depth
The existing individual. Kierkegaard's complaint against Hegel, and against the comfortable Christianity of Denmark, is that both forget what it is to be an existing person who must choose how to live. A system of thought can be completed; a life cannot be until it is over. He therefore writes indirectly, through pseudonymous authors with different points of view, so that the reader is thrown back on a decision and not handed a result.
Stages of life. The aesthetic life seeks the interesting and avoids commitment; its end is boredom and despair. The ethical life chooses itself, takes on duties and accepts the universal, as in marriage. Either/Or sets the two side by side. Beyond them is the religious life, in which the individual stands alone before God.
Abraham. Fear and Trembling considers Abraham's readiness to sacrifice Isaac. By the standard of ethics he is a murderer. If he is the father of faith, then faith involves a teleological suspension of the ethical: the single individual stands in an absolute relation to the absolute, higher than the universal. This cannot be explained or justified to others. The pseudonymous author says he can admire Abraham but cannot understand him.
Truth is subjectivity. In the Postscript Climacus argues that for questions of existence, what matters is not only what is believed but how. An objective uncertainty held fast in the most passionate inwardness is the highest truth available to an existing person. Christianity's claim that the eternal entered time is an absolute paradox that reason cannot absorb. The phrase leap of faith is a later summary; his term is the leap.
Anxiety and despair. Anxiety is the dizziness of freedom, awareness of possibility before any choice. Despair, the sickness unto death, is a misrelation in the self: not willing to be oneself, or willing to be a self of one's own making. The cure is that the self rests transparently in the power that established it.
Reading him. The pseudonyms do not agree, and Kierkegaard asked that their views not be attributed to him. Whether he was an irrationalist is disputed. The existentialists of the twentieth century took his categories and usually left out his Christianity.
The life behind the works. Kierkegaard lived in Copenhagen on an inheritance from his father, a stern and melancholy wool merchant. In 1840 he became engaged to Regine Olsen and a year later broke it off, convinced that he could not marry. The event runs through the early books. In 1846 he provoked a satirical newspaper, the Corsair, into mocking him, and was caricatured in the streets. In his final year he attacked the state church in a series of pamphlets, collapsed in the street, and died at forty-two.
Either/Or. The book is presented as papers found in a secondhand desk. The first part contains the writings of a young aesthete, including the Diary of a Seducer, for whom the worst thing is boredom and life is an experiment in avoiding it. The second contains letters from a judge who defends marriage and argues that the aesthete is in despair. The judge does not urge a choice between good and evil but the choice by which good and evil come to matter. No narrator says who is right.
The knight of faith. Fear and Trembling contrasts two figures. The knight of infinite resignation gives up what he loves most and finds peace in the renunciation. The knight of faith makes the same movement and then, by virtue of the absurd, believes he will receive it back in this life. Outwardly he looks like a tax collector out for a Sunday walk. Abraham is such a knight, and he cannot explain himself, since ethics speaks in universal terms and his relation to God is private.
The sickness unto death. Despair, in the book of that name, is a misrelation in the self. It has forms: not to be conscious of having a self; in weakness, not to will to be oneself; in defiance, to will to be oneself on one's own terms. The self is a relation that relates itself to itself and rests in the power that established it. The opposite of despair is faith, in which the self rests transparently in that power.
Indirect communication. Kierkegaard held that ethical and religious truth cannot be handed over as information. The reader has to be brought to appropriate it personally, and so must be left alone with it. Hence the pseudonyms, the irony and the unfinished arguments. Alongside them he published plainly religious discourses under his own name, and he asked to be remembered as a religious author.
Works
- Either/Or, 1843
- Fear and Trembling, 1843
- The Concept of Anxiety, 1844
- Concluding Unscientific Postscript, 1846
- The Sickness unto Death, 1849
A common misreading
Views stated in the pseudonymous books cannot simply be attributed to Kierkegaard. He asked readers to cite the pseudonym, not him, when quoting those works.
Influenced by
Socrates, G.W.F. Hegel, Blaise Pascal, Augustine of Hippo
Influenced
Martin Heidegger, Jean-Paul Sartre, Albert Camus, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Emmanuel Levinas
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Søren Kierkegaard in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.