Theodor W. Adorno
Leading thinker of the Frankfurt School, who analysed how reason, culture and art are shaped and damaged by modern capitalist society.
Life
Adorno was born in Frankfurt and trained both as a philosopher and as a composer, studying in Vienna with Alban Berg. Forced out of his university post in 1933, he went to Oxford and then to the United States, where he rejoined the exiled Institute for Social Research and worked with Max Horkheimer.
He returned to Frankfurt in 1949 and became the Institute's director and a prominent public voice in West Germany. In his last year he was in conflict with radical students who disrupted his lectures.
Core ideas
- Enlightenment, in seeking to master nature, turns into a new form of domination and myth.
- The “culture industry” mass-produces entertainment that standardises taste and pacifies its consumers.
- Negative dialectics: thought must resist the urge to make concepts fully capture their objects.
- Philosophy after Auschwitz must reckon with the fact that such a thing was possible.
- Serious art preserves a truth about society through its form, by refusing easy reconciliation.
In more depth
Dialectic of Enlightenment. Written with Horkheimer in exile, this book asks why humanity, instead of entering a truly human condition, is sinking into a new kind of barbarism. Its thesis is that enlightenment, the effort to free people from fear by mastering nature, turns into its opposite. Reason becomes purely instrumental, a calculation of means, and the domination of nature extends to the domination of human beings. Myth is already enlightenment, and enlightenment reverts to mythology.
The culture industry. Film, radio and popular music are produced like other commodities. They are standardised, offer the appearance of choice among identical things, and train their consumers to accept the existing order. Amusement becomes the prolongation of work. Critics have found the account too sweeping, especially about jazz.
Identity and the non-identical. Conceptual thought classifies things under general terms and so treats what is different as the same. Adorno calls this identity thinking and links it to the exchange of commodities, which also makes unlike things equivalent. Negative dialectics is the attempt to think against this tendency, to attend to what the concept leaves out, without claiming a final synthesis. Against Hegel he writes that the whole is the false.
After Auschwitz. He held that the catastrophe imposed a new categorical imperative: to arrange thought and action so that Auschwitz will not repeat itself. The remark that to write poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric, which he later qualified, expresses doubt that culture can go on as before.
Wrong life. Minima Moralia, a book of aphorisms on damaged life, contains the sentence that wrong life cannot be lived rightly. Private morality is compromised by the society in which it is practised.
Art. Serious art, especially difficult modern art, preserves a truth by refusing to be reconciled with the world as it is. Its autonomy is its social criticism.
Objection. Habermas argued that a critique of reason so total undermines its own basis.
The life. Adorno was born in Frankfurt to a wine merchant of Jewish descent and a singer, studied composition in Vienna with Alban Berg, and wrote on music all his life. He left Germany in 1934, for Oxford and then the United States, where he worked on studies of radio and of the authoritarian personality and lived among other émigrés in Los Angeles. He returned in 1949. In 1969, after student protesters disrupted his lectures, he died of a heart attack on holiday.
Odysseus and the Sirens. The Dialectic of Enlightenment reads an episode of the Odyssey as the first document of bourgeois reason. Odysseus wants to hear the Sirens' song and survive. He stops his oarsmen's ears with wax and has himself tied to the mast. The workers row and hear nothing; the master hears and cannot act. Enjoyment is separated from labour, and mastery over nature is bought by mastery over oneself. Reason begins as renunciation.
The essay as form. Adorno rejected philosophy that starts from first principles and builds a system. He wrote in essays and aphorisms that circle their subject. Minima Moralia, composed in exile, consists of short reflections on damaged life: on gifts, on doors that slam shut, on hotel rooms. “The whole is the false”, he writes, reversing Hegel. And: “the splinter in your eye is the best magnifying glass.” The form is meant to resist the tidy concept.
Music. His writings on music are central. In Schoenberg's atonal works he heard a refusal of false harmony and a truthful record of suffering. In popular music and jazz he heard standardisation: parts made to be interchangeable and listeners trained to recognise and not to listen. The essays on jazz are widely criticised as uninformed. The underlying claim is that the form of a work carries social content.
Education after Auschwitz. In radio talks of the 1960s Adorno said that the first demand on all education is that Auschwitz not happen again. The conditions that produced it persist: coldness, the inability to identify with others, the readiness to go along. The only real power against it, he said, is autonomy, in Kant's sense: the power of reflection, of self-determination, of not cooperating.
Works
- Dialectic of Enlightenment (with Max Horkheimer), 1944; revised 1947
- Minima Moralia, 1951
- Negative Dialectics, 1966
- Aesthetic Theory, published posthumously, 1970
A common misreading
His remark that writing poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric is often taken as a ban on art. He later qualified it, writing that perennial suffering has as much right to expression as the tortured have to scream.
Influenced by
G.W.F. Hegel, Karl Marx, Immanuel Kant, Friedrich Nietzsche
Influenced
Schools and eras
Critical Theory, Marxism, Continental
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Theodor W. Adorno in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.