Daniel Dennett
American philosopher who explained mind, consciousness and free will as products of evolution and information processing.
Life
Dennett spent part of his childhood in Beirut, where his father, an intelligence officer, was posted. He studied with W.V.O. Quine at Harvard and with Gilbert Ryle at Oxford, and taught at Tufts University from 1971. He worked closely with scientists, wrote for general readers, and was one of the prominent public atheists of the 2000s.
Core ideas
- The intentional stance: to treat a system as having beliefs and desires is to predict it as a rational agent.
- Consciousness is not shown in a single inner theatre; the brain produces multiple drafts of narrative.
- Qualia, as philosophers define them, do not exist.
- Natural selection is an algorithmic process that produces design without a designer.
- Free will worth wanting is compatible with determinism.
In more depth
Three stances. We can predict a thing's behaviour in three ways. From the physical stance we use its physical constitution and the laws of nature. From the design stance we assume it will work as it was designed, as with an alarm clock. From the intentional stance we treat it as an agent with beliefs and desires that acts rationally. A chess computer is best predicted this way. Dennett holds that there is no further fact about whether a system really has beliefs beyond the fact that the stance works reliably.
The Cartesian theatre. Most people who reject dualism still picture a place in the brain where everything comes together and consciousness happens, as if on a stage before an inner audience. Dennett calls this the Cartesian theatre and argues there is no such place and no finish line. Many processes of interpretation run in parallel, and what we report as our experience is the draft that happens to win influence. Critics replied that the book should have been called Consciousness Explained Away.
Intuition pumps. Dennett coined the term for thought experiments built to push the reader toward a conclusion, and advised turning the knobs: vary the details and see whether the intuition survives. Of John Searle's Chinese room he said that we are asked to imagine a simple rule book when a real program would be staggeringly complex. Of Mary he argued that someone who really knew all the physical facts would not be surprised by red.
Cranes and skyhooks. A skyhook is an explanation that appeals to a mind-like force from above. A crane is a mechanism that does lifting while standing on the ground of earlier processes. Darwin's idea, Dennett argued, is a universal acid: it shows that all the design in the living world, including human minds and culture, was built by cranes. On free will he held that what matters is the capacity to respond to reasons and to avoid foreseen harms, which evolved, and which determinism does not threaten.
Works
- Brainstorms, 1978
- Elbow Room, 1984
- The Intentional Stance, 1987
- Consciousness Explained, 1991
- Darwin's Dangerous Idea, 1995
Influenced by
Gilbert Ryle, W.V.O. Quine, Ludwig Wittgenstein, David Hume
Related ideas
The hard problem of consciousness, Compatibilism
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Daniel Dennett in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.