Plato
Athenian philosopher whose dialogues set much of the agenda for Western metaphysics, epistemology, ethics and political thought.
Life
Plato was born into an aristocratic Athenian family around 428 or 427 BCE, during the Peloponnesian War. As a young man he joined the circle around Socrates, and the trial and execution of Socrates by the Athenian democracy in 399 BCE marked him deeply. Nearly all of his surviving works are dialogues in which Socrates is the leading speaker; Plato never appears as a speaker in his own voice.
Around 387 BCE he founded the Academy, a community for philosophical and mathematical study just outside the walls of Athens, where Aristotle studied for about twenty years. Ancient sources report three journeys to Syracuse in Sicily, the later two in a failed attempt to educate the young ruler Dionysius II. The main source for these journeys is the Seventh Letter, whose authenticity scholars dispute.
He taught and wrote at the Academy until his death around 348 or 347 BCE. Unusually for an ancient author, everything he is known to have published appears to have survived.
Core ideas
- The Forms: the things we perceive are imperfect, changing instances of unchanging realities such as Beauty and Justice, which are grasped by thought.
- Knowledge differs from true belief. It requires an account of why something is so, and its proper objects are stable and intelligible.
- The soul has three parts (reason, spirit and appetite). Justice in a person is the right ordering of the three under reason (Republic, Book IV).
- The just city mirrors the just soul, and should be governed by rulers educated in philosophy (Republic, Books V–VII).
- Learning as recollection: the soul recovers knowledge it already possesses (Meno, Phaedo).
- The Form of the Good is the highest object of knowledge and the source of the intelligibility of the other Forms.
In more depth
The problem. Plato inherited two convictions that seem to conflict. From Socrates he took the view that there must be definite answers to questions such as what justice is. From Heraclitus, as he read him, he took the view that the world the senses show is always changing and is never exactly anything. If knowledge needs a stable object and the sensible world offers none, then either knowledge is impossible or its objects lie elsewhere.
The Forms. Plato's answer is that there are Forms: Justice itself, Beauty itself, the Equal itself. Each is single, unchanging and grasped by thought. Sensible things are what they are by sharing in, or imitating, a Form, and they do so imperfectly. Two sticks are equal in one respect and unequal in another; the Equal itself is never unequal. In the Republic the Form of the Good stands above the rest as the source of their being and intelligibility, compared to the sun.
Knowledge as recollection. In the Meno a slave with no schooling is led by questions alone to a geometrical truth. Plato concludes that learning is the recovery of knowledge the soul already has, and in the Phaedo he uses this to argue that the soul existed before birth and is akin to the Forms. The divided line and the cave in the Republic set out the stages from opinion about appearances to understanding of Forms.
Soul and city. The Republic argues that justice is a kind of health. The soul has three parts: reason, spirit and appetite. The just soul is one in which reason rules with spirit's support. The city is the soul written large, with rulers, auxiliaries and producers, and it will be just only if those who love wisdom rule. Democracy is criticised as rule by appetite and opinion.
Plato against himself. In the Parmenides Plato puts serious objections to his own theory. How can one Form be in many things? If large things are large by sharing in the Large, and the Large is itself large, a further Form seems needed, and so on without end: the Third Man argument. The later dialogues rework the theory, and the Sophist explains how it is possible to say what is not.
Reading the dialogues. Plato never speaks in his own voice, the dialogues do not always agree, and their order of composition is partly conjecture. Some readers find a development from Socratic inquiry to a mature system and then to self-criticism. Others think the form is meant to provoke thinking, not to deliver doctrine.
The cave. In Republic VII prisoners chained in a cave see only shadows cast on a wall and take them for reality. One is freed, turns, is dazzled by the fire, and is dragged up into daylight, where he comes at last to see the sun. The image compresses the whole philosophy: the shadows are the opinions of ordinary life, the ascent is education, and the sun is the Form of the Good, which makes everything else knowable. The freed prisoner must go back down and will be mocked and perhaps killed, as Socrates was.
The divided line. Just before the cave, Plato divides a line into four segments: images, visible things, mathematical objects, and Forms. To each corresponds a state of mind, from imagination and belief up to reasoning and understanding. Mathematics is the bridge. The geometer reasons about the square itself and not the one drawn in the sand, yet still relies on diagrams and on assumptions left unexamined. Dialectic, the highest study, questions the assumptions themselves.
Love as a ladder. In the Symposium the priestess Diotima describes an ascent that begins with desire for one beautiful body, widens to all beautiful bodies, then to beautiful souls, laws and kinds of knowledge, and ends in a sudden vision of Beauty itself. Desire is not suppressed but redirected. The passage shows that for Plato knowledge is not detached: the philosopher is a lover, and the Forms are objects of longing as well as of thought.
The late dialogues. The later works revise more than they repeat. The Theaetetus tests three definitions of knowledge and rejects all of them, including true belief with an account. The Sophist explains how false statement is possible by treating “is not” as “is different from”. The Timaeus offers a “likely story” of a craftsman god who shapes the world on the model of the Forms. The Laws replaces the philosopher-kings with a detailed legal code. A reader who knows only the Republic knows half of Plato.
In their words
The unexamined life is not worth living for a human being.
Works
- Apology, c. 399–390 BCE
- Meno, c. 385 BCE
- Phaedo, c. 380 BCE
- Symposium, c. 385–370 BCE
- Republic, c. 375 BCE
- Parmenides, c. 370–360 BCE
- Theaetetus, c. 369 BCE
- Timaeus, c. 360 BCE
- Laws, c. 350s BCE, unfinished at his death
No dialogue can be dated precisely. The order shown follows the conventional division into early, middle and late periods, which rests partly on stylistic analysis.
Where scholars disagree
Scholars disagree about how far the Socrates of the dialogues speaks for Plato, and about whether Plato's views stayed constant (the unitarian reading) or changed substantially between periods (the developmentalist reading).
A common misreading
"Platonic love" is often taken to mean affection without desire. In the Symposium, the ascent to the love of Beauty itself begins with erotic attraction to a beautiful body; desire is redirected and enlarged, not absent.
Influenced by
Socrates, Heraclitus, Parmenides, Pythagoras
Influenced
Aristotle, Plotinus, Augustine of Hippo, al-Farabi
Related ideas
Theory of Forms, Socratic method, The Euthyphro dilemma
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Plato in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.