Plotinus
Founder of Neoplatonism, who derived all reality from a single ineffable source, the One.
Life
Plotinus was probably born in Egypt and studied philosophy for eleven years in Alexandria under Ammonius Saccas. In 243 he joined a military expedition against Persia in the hope of learning Persian and Indian philosophy. It failed, and he settled in Rome, where he taught for the rest of his life.
He began writing at about fifty. His pupil Porphyry edited the treatises into six groups of nine, the Enneads, and wrote a biography that is our main source for his life.
Core ideas
- The One (or the Good) is the source of everything, beyond being and beyond thought.
- From the One proceeds Intellect, containing the Platonic Forms, and from Intellect proceeds Soul, which orders the physical world.
- Matter is the last and weakest product of this process, and evil is a lack of form and goodness.
- The soul can return to its source by turning inward, culminating in union with the One.
In more depth
The three principles. Plotinus presents himself as an interpreter of Plato, but he builds from Plato a single system. Reality has three levels. At the top is the One, also called the Good. Below it is Intellect, and below that Soul. The sensible world is the last and weakest expression of the same reality.
The One. Whatever exists is one thing, and a complex unity depends on something simpler. The first principle must therefore be absolutely simple. It cannot think, since thinking involves a difference between thinker and object, and it cannot even be said to be in the ordinary sense, since being belongs to definite things. It can be spoken of only by saying what it is not, or by pointing to what comes from it.
Emanation. From the One, Intellect proceeds, not by a decision or in time, but as light comes from the sun without diminishing it. Intellect is the realm of Plato's Forms, here understood as the contents of a mind that thinks them all at once. Soul proceeds from Intellect and brings order, life and time to bodies. Each level looks back toward its source, and by that turning becomes what it is.
Matter and evil. Matter is the point at which the outflow of form gives out. It is sheer privation, and Plotinus identifies it with evil, though evil for him is a lack and not a rival power. Against the Gnostics he insists that the sensible world, as an image of the intelligible, is as good as an image can be.
The return. The soul's task is to reverse the descent: to turn from the body to itself, from itself to Intellect, and finally to union with the One, in which the distinction between seer and seen disappears. Porphyry says Plotinus reached this state four times while they were together. Augustine and later Jewish, Christian and Islamic thinkers took over much of this structure.
The life. What we know comes from the Life written by his pupil Porphyry. Plotinus studied for eleven years at Alexandria under Ammonius Saccas, joined a military expedition to the east hoping to learn Persian and Indian philosophy, and then taught in Rome for twenty-five years. Porphyry says he seemed ashamed of being in a body and would not sit for a portrait. He wrote his treatises only in later life, and Porphyry arranged them in six groups of nine, the Enneads.
Why the One is beyond being. Anything that is something definite has a form, and so is a combination of unity and something else. Its unity must come from elsewhere. The source of all unity cannot itself be a combination, so it has no form, no parts and no predicates. Even to call it “one” or “good” is to speak of what it is for us. Plotinus therefore says that the One is beyond being and beyond thought, since thinking requires a thinker and something thought.
Beauty. The early treatise On Beauty rejects the common view that beauty is symmetry of parts, since simple things such as light and a single tone are beautiful. A thing is beautiful by sharing in form, which makes it one. The beauty of bodies leads the soul to recall the beauty of virtue and knowledge, and beyond these the source of beauty itself. He borrows a sculptor's image: work on your own statue, cutting away what is excessive, until the inner light shows.
Soul and its descent. Each individual soul is a part or aspect of the one Soul, and it has not wholly come down: its highest part remains in the intelligible world, though we are usually unaware of it. Descent into a body is both a necessity, since Soul must order what is below it, and a kind of fault, a wish for self-rule. This double valuation of embodied life, as required and yet as a fall, runs through later Platonism and into Christian thought.
Works
- Enneads (edited by Porphyry), written c. 253–270 CE; published c. 301 CE
A common misreading
Plotinus did not think of himself as founding a new philosophy. “Neoplatonism” is a modern term; he regarded himself simply as an interpreter of Plato.
Influenced by
Influenced
Augustine of Hippo, Boethius, al-Farabi, Ibn Sina (Avicenna)
Schools and eras
Neoplatonism, Platonism, Hellenistic and Roman
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Plotinus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.