Peter Abelard
The leading logician of the twelfth century, who denied that universals are real things and made intention the basis of ethics.
Life
Abelard was born in Brittany and made his name in the schools of Paris by defeating his own teachers in debate. His love affair with his pupil Heloise ended with their secret marriage, his castration by agents of her uncle, and the entry of both into religious life. Their later letters are famous.
He continued to teach and attracted large numbers of students. His theology was condemned at church councils in 1121 and again in 1141, the second time at the urging of Bernard of Clairvaux. He died under the protection of the abbot of Cluny.
Core ideas
- Universals are words, not things: only individuals exist, and general terms apply to many of them (see the Problem of universals).
- The moral worth of an act lies in the agent's intention or consent, not in the deed or its results.
- Apparent contradictions among authorities should be set side by side and resolved by reason (Sic et Non).
- “By doubting we come to inquiry, and by inquiry we perceive the truth” (Sic et Non, Prologue).
In more depth
Universals. Abelard attacked the realism of his teacher William of Champeaux, who held that one and the same thing is present in all members of a species. If the same humanity were wholly in Socrates and wholly in Plato, Socrates would be where Plato is. Abelard concluded that only individuals exist. Universality belongs to words, and specifically to words as meaningful, not as sounds.
What grounds general words. If nothing is common to all humans, why does the word apply to all of them? Abelard's answer is that they agree in being human. This is not a thing they share; it is a status, the way each of them is. General words also give rise to a common conception in the mind, an image of no one in particular. The position is a nominalism that still ties language to how things are.
Ethics of intention. In his Ethics Abelard separates four things: a vice of character, the desire to do wrong, the deed itself, and consent to the deed. Only consent, the inner decision to do what one believes one ought not, is sin. What makes an act good or bad is therefore the agent's intention, not the outward deed. Desire is no sin if resisted, and the outward deed adds nothing to the guilt. Two people may perform the same act, one sinning and one not, depending on what each intends.
A hard consequence. He accepted that those who crucified Christ believing they were doing right did not sin in so acting, though they would have sinned more gravely had they acted against conscience. Critics saw this as making morality subjective. Abelard held that right intention requires that what one believes to be pleasing to God is in fact so.
Method. Sic et Non sets out apparently contradictory statements from Scripture and the Fathers on 158 questions, without resolving them, together with rules for interpretation. The collection became a model for the scholastic method of arguing both sides before deciding.
The dispute with William. Abelard recounts how as a student in Paris he forced his teacher William of Champeaux to abandon his theory of universals. William held that the same essence is wholly present in each member of a species, which differ only by their accidents. Abelard replied that the same thing would then have contrary properties at once: rational in Socrates and irrational in the donkey Brunellus, if they share the essence animal. William retreated to a weaker position, and Abelard attacked that too.
Status. Abelard's own view is that only individuals exist, and that a universal is a word. But a general word is not arbitrary. Socrates and Plato agree in being men. “Being a man” is not a thing; Abelard calls it a status, a way things are, and it is the common cause of our applying the word to each. The mind forms a general notion by attending to some features and ignoring others, which he compares to an image that is of no one in particular.
Sic et Non. Abelard collected 158 questions on which the Church Fathers appear to contradict one another, set out the texts for yes and no, and left them unresolved. The prologue gives rules for resolving them: check for corrupt texts, for changes in the meaning of words, for opinions later retracted. By doubting we come to inquiry, he writes, and by inquiry we perceive the truth. The method became the standard form of scholastic teaching.
The life. Abelard's autobiography, the History of My Calamities, tells of his fame as a teacher, his love affair with his pupil Heloise, their secret marriage, his castration by agents of her uncle, and the entry of both into religious life. Their later letters are among the best-known documents of the Middle Ages, and Heloise's show a philosophical mind of her own. He was condemned twice for his theology, the second time in 1141 at the instigation of Bernard of Clairvaux, and died the following year under the protection of the abbot of Cluny.
Works
- Sic et Non (Yes and No), c. 1121
- The Story of My Misfortunes, c. 1132
- Ethics (Know Yourself), c. 1138
- Dialectica, c. 1115–1140
A common misreading
Abelard is often remembered only for the romance with Heloise. In his own time he was known above all as a logician, and Heloise was an accomplished scholar in her own right.
Influenced by
Aristotle, Boethius, Augustine of Hippo
Influenced
Thomas Aquinas, William of Ockham
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Peter Abelard in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.