Richard Rorty
American philosopher who rejected the idea that knowledge mirrors reality and recast pragmatism for the late twentieth century.
Life
Rorty was the child of left-wing writers who had broken with the Communist Party. He entered the University of Chicago at fifteen, made his name as an analytic philosopher at Princeton, and then turned against the assumptions of the field. He moved to a humanities chair at Virginia and later to comparative literature at Stanford.
Core ideas
- The picture of the mind as a mirror of nature, and of philosophy as the judge of its accuracy, should be abandoned.
- Truth is not a goal of inquiry distinct from justification to our peers.
- Vocabularies are tools for coping, not representations of how things are in themselves.
- The ironist knows that her deepest beliefs are contingent and holds them all the same.
- Solidarity is created by enlarging our sense of “we”, not discovered in human nature.
In more depth
The mirror. Since Descartes, Locke and Kant, philosophy has seen itself as the discipline that explains how the mind represents the world and so decides which claims to knowledge are sound. Rorty argues, using Quine, Sellars and Davidson, that this self-image rests on optional metaphors. Justification is a social practice of giving reasons, and nothing stands outside all such practices to underwrite them. Philosophy should give up the role of judge and become one voice in the conversation of mankind.
Truth. To say that a belief is true is to pay it a compliment, to caution that it might yet be revised, or to endorse it. There is nothing more general to say. Rorty denied the charge of relativism: he did not say that every view is as good as every other, only that we can do no better than justify our views to as many audiences as we can. Critics, including Hilary Putnam and Jürgen Habermas, replied that this drops the difference between being justified and being right.
The liberal ironist. A final vocabulary is the set of words a person uses to justify her actions and her life. The ironist has doubts about hers, knows these doubts cannot be settled by argument within it, and does not think it closer to reality than others. Liberals are people who think cruelty is the worst thing we do. Rorty wanted both: private irony and public commitment to reducing cruelty, with no theory to unite them.
Novels and the left. Moral progress comes less from theory than from detailed descriptions of what unfamiliar people are like and what cruelty looks like: from journalism, ethnography and above all the novel. In Achieving Our Country he criticised the academic left for abandoning economic reform for cultural theory, and predicted that neglected workers would one day turn to a strongman.
Works
- Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature, 1979
- Consequences of Pragmatism, 1982
- Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity, 1989
- Achieving Our Country, 1998
Influenced by
John Dewey, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Martin Heidegger, Donald Davidson, W.V.O. Quine, William James
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Richard Rorty in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.