Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Robert Nozick

1938 CE – 2002 CE · Brooklyn, New York; Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA · North American

American philosopher who gave the most influential philosophical defence of the minimal, libertarian state.

Life

Nozick was born in Brooklyn to a family of Russian-Jewish immigrants, studied at Columbia and Princeton, and became a full professor at Harvard at thirty. He was a colleague of John Rawls, to whose theory his first book was in part a reply.

He did not return to political philosophy afterwards, and wrote instead on knowledge, personal identity, rationality and the meaning of life, preferring to explore questions than to defend positions.

Core ideas

In more depth

Rights as side constraints. Nozick begins from the claim that individuals have rights, and there are things no person or group may do to them. Rights are not goals to be maximised. They are constraints on action, reflecting the Kantian principle that persons are ends and not merely means, and the fact that each has a separate life to lead.

The minimal state. Against the anarchist he argues that a state limited to protection against force, theft and fraud, and to the enforcement of contracts, would arise from a state of nature without violating anyone's rights, as competing protection agencies gave way to a dominant one. Any more extensive state violates rights.

The entitlement theory. Justice in holdings has three parts: justice in original acquisition, justice in transfer, and rectification of past injustice. A distribution is just if everyone is entitled to what they hold under these principles. The theory is historical: what matters is how a distribution came about, not its pattern. Theories such as Rawls's, which require holdings to match a pattern, are of a different kind.

Wilt Chamberlain. Suppose holdings are distributed by your favourite pattern. Many people then each freely pay a small sum to watch a basketball star, who ends up rich. The pattern is upset by voluntary acts. To maintain any pattern, Nozick concludes, requires continual interference with people's choices. He adds that taxation of earnings from labour is on a par with forced labour.

The experience machine. Elsewhere in the book he asks whether one would plug into a machine that supplied any experiences one wished. Most would not, which suggests that we want to do things and be a certain way, not merely to have experiences.

Objections. Critics say he gives no foundation for the rights he assumes, that his account of original acquisition is thin, and that the Chamberlain argument assumes full property rights from the start. His later books turned to knowledge, personal identity and the meaning of life, and he partly drew back from libertarianism.

The life. Nozick grew up in Brooklyn, the son of a Russian Jewish immigrant, and was a socialist as a student. Arguments with libertarian friends at Princeton changed his mind. Anarchy, State, and Utopia appeared in 1974, three years after his Harvard colleague Rawls's book, and won the National Book Award. He never wrote on political philosophy at length again and said he did not want to spend his life defending one book.

How a state arises. The first part answers the anarchist. In a state of nature people would join mutual protection associations. Through competition one agency would come to dominate a territory. It may then rightly forbid independents from enforcing their own claims by unreliable procedures, provided it compensates them by protecting them too. The result is a minimal state that arose by an invisible-hand process without anyone's rights being violated.

Historical and patterned principles. Most theories of justice judge a distribution by its shape: who has what, compared to some formula such as need or merit. Nozick calls these patterned or end-state principles. His own theory is historical: whether a holding is just depends on how it came about. From each as they choose, to each as they are chosen. He accepts a proviso from Locke that an acquisition must not worsen the situation of others.

The framework for utopia. The third part argues that there is no single best society for everyone. The minimal state is a framework within which people may form whatever communities they wish, communist, religious or commercial, so long as no one is compelled to stay. It is inspiring as well as right, he says, because it treats us as inviolate individuals who may not be used by others.

Later work. Philosophical Explanations proposes that knowledge is belief that tracks the truth: you know something if you would not believe it were it false, and would believe it were it true. The account implies that knowledge is not closed under known implication, which gives a reply to scepticism. In The Examined Life he wrote that his earlier libertarian position now seemed to him seriously inadequate, though he later said that reports of his abandoning libertarianism were much exaggerated.

Works

A common misreading

Nozick is sometimes assumed to have remained a strict libertarian. In The Examined Life he wrote that the position he had once put forward now seemed to him “seriously inadequate”, though he did not abandon it altogether.

Influenced by

John Locke, Immanuel Kant, John Rawls

Schools and eras

Analytic

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Robert Nozick in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.