Pythagoras
Founder of a religious and philosophical community in southern Italy, remembered for teaching the transmigration of souls.
Life
Pythagoras was born on the island of Samos and emigrated around 530 BCE to Croton in southern Italy. There he founded a community whose members followed a strict way of life, with dietary rules, rituals and a reputation for secrecy. The community gained political influence in several cities and was later violently suppressed.
He wrote nothing, and legends gathered around him within a generation. Most of the detailed ancient “lives” were written some seven or eight centuries after his death, so little about him is certain.
Core ideas
- The soul is immortal and passes after death into other living bodies, including those of animals.
- A disciplined way of life, including abstention from certain foods, purifies the soul.
- Later Pythagoreans held that number and proportion underlie the order of the cosmos, and they discovered the numerical ratios of the musical intervals. How much of this goes back to Pythagoras himself is unclear.
In more depth
The difficulty. Pythagoras wrote nothing, his followers kept their teaching within the community, and later Pythagoreans credited their own discoveries to him. Almost every statement about him is therefore disputed. The earliest evidence presents him as a religious teacher and the founder of a way of life, and only later sources make him a mathematician.
The soul and its rebirth. The best-attested doctrine is that the soul is immortal and passes after death into other bodies, including those of animals. This grounded the community's rules of life, among them dietary restrictions, and it gave philosophy a new purpose: the purification of the soul. Plato's arguments for immortality in the Phaedo owe much to this tradition.
Number and harmony. Pythagoreans discovered that the musical intervals correspond to simple ratios of string lengths: the octave to 2:1, the fifth to 3:2, the fourth to 4:3. From this they generalised that the order of the whole cosmos is numerical, a harmony. Aristotle reports the view, with some puzzlement, as the claim that things are numbers. The idea that nature is intelligible through mathematics is the school's most consequential legacy.
What belongs to Pythagoras himself. The theorem that bears his name was known in Babylon long before him, and no early source credits him with proving it. The detailed mathematical and cosmological doctrines belong mainly to fifth-century Pythagoreans such as Philolaus. It is safest to speak of what the Pythagoreans held.
A way of life. The earliest reports describe a community in southern Italy bound by rules. Members observed silence, shared property by some accounts, and followed many prescriptions, the best known being abstention from beans and restrictions on eating meat. Some of the sayings handed down, such as not to stir the fire with a knife, were later explained as moral symbols. What matters philosophically is the idea that a doctrine about the soul should govern the details of daily conduct, and that philosophy is practised in a community.
The tetractys. The Pythagoreans revered the arrangement of ten points in a triangle of four rows: one, two, three and four. The first four numbers contain the ratios of the basic musical concords, and they sum to ten, which was held to be the perfect number. The figure joined arithmetic, geometry and music in one image. From the same circle came the idea that the heavenly bodies, moving at distances in proportion, produce a harmony that we do not hear because it has sounded in our ears since birth.
The crisis of the incommensurable. If all things are number, and number means whole numbers and their ratios, then every length should be a ratio of whole numbers to any other. The diagonal of a square is not: no ratio of whole numbers equals the square root of two. The discovery, made within the school in the fifth century, showed that geometry outruns arithmetic. Stories that its discoverer was drowned for revealing it are late legend, but they show how deeply the result was felt.
Through Plato. Plato visited the Pythagoreans of southern Italy, and the influence is plain: the immortal soul and its rebirths, the mathematical education of the guardians, the cosmos built from ratios in the Timaeus. Because Plato's successors then read their own Platonism back into Pythagoras, the later picture of him as a mathematical metaphysician is partly a reflection of Plato.
Works
- No writings; the teachings were transmitted orally, —
Where scholars disagree
Scholars disagree sharply about whether Pythagoras was a mathematician and natural philosopher at all, or chiefly a religious teacher to whom later followers attributed their own discoveries.
A common misreading
There is no reliable evidence that Pythagoras proved the theorem that carries his name. The relationship was known in Babylonia centuries earlier, and the attribution of a proof to him comes from late and doubtful sources.
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Pythagoras in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.