Parmenides
Author of a philosophical poem arguing that what is cannot come to be, perish or change, the first sustained deductive argument in Western philosophy.
Life
Parmenides came from Elea, a Greek city in southern Italy, and is said to have written laws for it. His birth date is uncertain: Plato's dialogue Parmenides implies about 515 BCE, while another ancient chronology puts it some decades earlier.
He set out his philosophy in a single poem in epic verse. A goddess reveals to the narrator first the “Way of Truth” and then the “Way of Opinion”, an account of the world as mortals believe it to be. About 150 lines survive.
Core ideas
- One can think and speak only of what is. What is not cannot be thought or said.
- What is did not come to be and will not perish, since it would have to come from or pass into what is not.
- What is, is whole, continuous and unchanging.
- The senses, which report change and plurality, are not to be trusted against argument.
In more depth
The argument. In Parmenides' poem a goddess sets out the only possible routes of inquiry. One says that what is, is, and cannot not be. The other says that it is not, and this route cannot be followed, because what is not can be neither thought nor spoken of: there is nothing there to think. From this beginning everything else follows by deduction.
What follows. What is cannot have come into being, since it would have had to come from what is not, and that is unthinkable. For the same reason it cannot perish. It cannot be more here and less there, since that would require some admixture of what is not. So it is ungenerated, imperishable, whole, unchanging and complete. Coming-to-be, perishing, motion and plurality, which the senses report, are ruled out by reason.
The Way of Opinion. The second part of the poem gives a cosmology of light and night, introduced as the deceptive opinions of mortals. Why Parmenides included it is among the oldest disputes in the subject. It may be the best account that can be given of appearances, or a demonstration of the error to avoid.
Why it mattered. This is the first sustained deductive argument in Western philosophy, and it set reason against the senses in a way nobody could ignore. Every later natural philosopher accepted its central point, that nothing comes from nothing. Empedocles, Anaxagoras and the atomists each explained change as the rearrangement of things that are themselves ungenerated and unchanging. Plato's Forms inherit the marks of Parmenides' being.
The proem. The poem opens with a journey. Mares draw the speaker's chariot, with daughters of the Sun as guides, through the gates of Night and Day to a goddess who takes his hand and promises to teach him both the unshaken heart of well-rounded truth and the opinions of mortals in which there is no true trust. The setting borrows the authority of epic and of religious revelation. But what the goddess delivers is an argument, and she tells him to judge it by reason.
Thinking and being. One line says that it is the same thing that can be thought and that can be. On the most common reading this means that thought must have a real object: you cannot think of nothing. The consequence is severe. Any statement that implies that something is not, such as that a thing came into being, or is here and not there, or was one way and is now another, turns out to be about nothing and so says nothing. Ordinary speech about change is, strictly, empty.
Like a sphere. The goddess concludes that what is, being complete on every side, is like the bulk of a well-rounded ball, equally poised from the centre in every direction. Whether this is a comparison or a literal claim that reality is a finite sphere has been argued since antiquity. Melissus, a follower, corrected it and argued that what is must be infinite, since a limit would border on what is not.
How to read the two parts. On one modern reading Parmenides denies that the many changing things exist at all. On another he is setting conditions that anything fundamentally real must meet, namely to be ungenerated and unchanging, and leaving it open that there are several such things. The second reading explains why Empedocles, Anaxagoras and the atomists felt free to posit many basic entities, each as changeless as Parmenides required.
Works
- On Nature (poem; about 150 lines survive), c. 475 BCE
Where scholars disagree
The status of the “Way of Opinion” is contested: it may be a deliberately false cosmology, the best available account of appearances, or a legitimate second-level description of the world.
A common misreading
Parmenides is usually said to have taught that only one thing exists. Many scholars now read him as setting conditions on what any real thing must be like, without committing himself to there being numerically one thing.
Influenced by
Influenced
Zeno of Elea, Empedocles, Democritus, Plato
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Parmenides in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.