The Euthyphro dilemma
The question whether what is good is good because God commands it, or God commands it because it is good.
Explanation
In Plato's Euthyphro, Socrates asks whether the pious is loved by the gods because it is pious, or is pious because they love it. Applied to morality and a single God, the question has two answers, and each has a cost. If things are good because God commands them, then morality seems arbitrary: had God commanded cruelty, cruelty would be good, and calling God good says only that he does what he wills. If God commands things because they are good, then goodness is independent of God.
The first answer is called divine command theory or voluntarism, and versions were held by William of Ockham and in the Ash'arite school of Islamic theology. The second was held by the Mu'tazilites and by many rationalists.
Critics
A common reply, drawing on Thomas Aquinas, rejects both horns: goodness is neither above God nor decided by his will, but is his own nature. Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz argued that voluntarism destroys the love of God, since one cannot praise him for doing what is good.
Thomas Aquinas, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
Where scholars disagree
The same structure recurs outside religion: is something right because society approves it, or approved because it is right?
Originator
Related ideas
Problem of evil, Socratic method
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open The Euthyphro dilemma in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.