Pascal's wager
An argument that it is rational to commit oneself to belief in God even without proof, given what is at stake.
Explanation
Blaise Pascal grants that reason cannot settle whether God exists. But we cannot avoid choosing how to live, so we are in effect placing a bet. If God exists and we have wagered that he does, the gain is infinite; if God does not exist, we have lost little. If we wager against God and are wrong, the loss is immense. The prudent bet is on God.
The argument is one of the earliest uses of what is now called decision theory. Pascal knew that belief cannot simply be chosen, and he advises the unbeliever to act as believers do, which will in time bring belief. The passage is a single fragment in the Pensées, headed “Infinite–nothing”.
Critics
The “many gods” objection, pressed by Diderot, notes that rival religions offer rival rewards. Voltaire found the appeal to self-interest unworthy of the subject, and William James remarked that a deity might take pleasure in excluding believers of this calculating kind.
Where scholars disagree
Scholars disagree about whether the fragment contains one argument or several distinct ones, and about how Pascal meant it to fit into his planned defence of Christianity.
Originator
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Pascal's wager in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.