Zeno of Elea
Follower of Parmenides whose paradoxes of motion and plurality have occupied philosophers and mathematicians ever since.
Life
Zeno was a fellow citizen and close associate of Parmenides. Plato's Parmenides depicts the two visiting Athens together and has Zeno explain that his book was written to defend Parmenides by showing that his critics' assumptions lead to absurdities worse than his own.
Later stories tell of his death resisting a tyrant, but they conflict with one another. His book is lost, and the paradoxes are known mainly from Aristotle's Physics and from the commentator Simplicius.
Core ideas
- If there are many things, contradictions follow: they must be both limited and unlimited in number, both so small as to have no size and so large as to be infinite.
- Motion is impossible, as argued in the paradoxes of the Dichotomy, Achilles, the Arrow and the Stadium.
- A method of refuting a thesis by deriving contradictory consequences from it, later called reductio ad absurdum.
In more depth
The purpose. According to Plato, Zeno wrote to defend Parmenides against those who mocked the claim that reality is one and unchanging. His method was to grant the opponents' assumption, that there are many things or that things move, and to deduce contradictions from it. Aristotle called him the inventor of dialectic for this reason.
Against plurality. If there are many things, each must have some size, and so parts, and those parts further parts without end; then each thing is infinitely large. Or the parts have no size, and then nothing made of them has any. So if there are many things they are both so small as to have no size and so large as to be unlimited.
Against motion. Aristotle reports four arguments. In the Dichotomy, a runner must first reach the halfway point, then half of what remains, and so on without end. In the Achilles, the faster runner must first reach where the slower one was, by which time the slower has moved on. In the Arrow, at any instant the arrow occupies a space equal to itself and so is at rest; if time is made of instants it never moves. The fourth, the Moving Rows, concerns bodies passing one another and is harder to reconstruct. (Names vary: some sources call the fourth argument the Stadium, others give that name to the Dichotomy.)
The replies. Aristotle distinguished actual from potential infinity: a distance can be divided without limit but is not actually composed of infinitely many parts. The modern reply to the Dichotomy and Achilles uses convergent series, by which infinitely many intervals sum to a finite length and time. Whether that removes every difficulty about completing an endless sequence of tasks is still debated, and the Arrow raises separate questions about motion at an instant.
The numbers in the Achilles. Give the tortoise a start of 100 metres and let Achilles run ten times as fast. When Achilles has run 100, the tortoise is 10 ahead; when he has run 10 more, it is 1 ahead; then a tenth of a metre, and so on. The distances Achilles must cover are 100 + 10 + 1 + 0.1 and so on, which sum to 111 and one ninth metres. He overtakes the tortoise there. The arithmetic shows where; the philosophical question is how an unending series of runs is ever finished.
The Arrow more carefully. The argument assumes that at an instant the arrow occupies a space exactly its own size, and that what occupies such a space is at rest. Aristotle answered that time is not made of instants, and that neither motion nor rest is possible at an instant, only over a period. The modern account defines velocity at an instant as a limit of average velocities over shrinking intervals. On that account the arrow does have a velocity at each instant, but only by virtue of where it is at other times.
The millet seed. A bushel of millet makes a noise when it falls. A single seed, or a ten-thousandth part of a seed, makes none. But the bushel is nothing other than its seeds, so the noise should be the sum of the noises of the parts. The argument attacks the reliability of the senses and raises the question, still alive, of how a whole can have a property that none of its parts has.
Why the paradoxes last. The paradoxes are arguments with true-seeming premises and an unacceptable conclusion, so each proposed solution must say which premise is false, and that has consequences. Aristotle's answer required his theory of the potential infinite. The mathematical answer required the theory of limits, built in the nineteenth century. Each generation has had to settle its view of space, time and infinity before it could answer Zeno.
Works
- A book of arguments (lost; reported by later authors), c. 460 BCE
A common misreading
Zeno was not simply denying the evidence of the senses for the sake of it. On Plato's account, his arguments were aimed at people who mocked Parmenides, and their purpose was to show that belief in plurality and motion is at least as paradoxical.
Influenced by
Influenced
Socrates, Democritus, Aristotle
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Zeno of Elea in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.