Democritus
Co-founder of ancient atomism, who held that reality consists only of atoms moving in the void.
Life
Democritus was born in Abdera, in northern Greece, and is said to have travelled widely. He was a younger contemporary of Socrates and wrote on an enormous range of subjects, including physics, mathematics, ethics and music. Later tradition called him “the laughing philosopher”.
He developed the atomic theory first proposed by Leucippus, a shadowy figure about whom almost nothing is known, and ancient sources often do not separate the contributions of the two. None of his many books survives. The physical theory is known mostly through Aristotle's criticisms, while the surviving fragments are mainly ethical sayings.
Core ideas
- Atoms and void: there are infinitely many indivisible bodies, differing in shape and size, moving in empty space.
- All compound things, and all change, result from the collision and entanglement of atoms. Nothing happens at random; everything happens by necessity.
- Qualities such as sweet, bitter, hot and colour exist “by convention”; in reality there are atoms and void.
- The goal of life is cheerfulness (euthymia), a settled state of mind reached through moderation.
In more depth
Atoms and void. Parmenides had argued that what is not cannot be. Leucippus and Democritus replied that what is not, the void, exists no less than what is. The world consists of the full and the empty. The full is divided into countless atoms, each solid, uncuttable, ungenerated and indestructible, so that each atom has the character of Parmenides' being. Because there is void between them, they can move, and there can be many of them.
Explaining the world. Atoms differ only in shape, size, arrangement and position. Aristotle illustrates with letters: A differs from N in shape, AN from NA in arrangement. Everything else is explained by these differences and by the collisions and entanglements of atoms. Worlds form where atoms happen to gather in a vortex; there are innumerable worlds, and ours has no special place.
Convention and reality. A fragment says that by convention there is sweet, bitter, hot, cold and colour, but in reality atoms and void. Sensory qualities are effects of atoms on the perceiver, not features of things themselves. Democritus saw the difficulty this creates. In another fragment the senses answer the mind: you take your evidence from us and then overthrow us; your victory is your fall.
Ethics and legacy. Most of the surviving fragments are ethical. They recommend cheerfulness, a settled state of mind reached through moderation and by not wanting what is out of reach. Epicurus rebuilt his physics on atomism a century later. The early modern distinction between primary and secondary qualities restates Democritus' contrast between atoms and convention.
Why there must be indivisibles. Suppose a body could be divided at every point. Carry the division through. What remains? Not bodies with size, for these could be divided further. Not points without size, for no number of such points adds up to a size. Not nothing, for then the body was made of nothing. So division must stop at parts that have size and cannot be cut. The argument, reported by Aristotle, answers Zeno by denying that physical division can go on without limit.
Necessity without purpose. Leucippus is credited with the one sentence of his that survives: nothing happens at random, but everything for a reason and by necessity. In atomism this means that every event follows from the earlier motions and collisions of atoms. There is no mind arranging things and no goal toward which they tend. Plato never mentions Democritus by name, and Aristotle criticised the atomists precisely for leaving out the cause “for the sake of which”.
Two kinds of knowing. Democritus distinguishes a dark or bastard kind of knowledge, to which sight, hearing, smell, taste and touch belong, from a genuine kind, which takes over when the senses can no longer see or hear anything smaller. Reason reaches the atoms that the senses cannot. But the evidence for atoms is the behaviour of the visible world, so reason depends on the witnesses it discredits. He states the difficulty himself and does not claim to have removed it.
Images and gods. Perception is explained by thin films of atoms that bodies continually shed and that enter the eye. Dreams and belief in gods come from the same source: large and long-lasting images that drift toward people. The explanation is typical of the school. A belief is accounted for by its physical cause without being accepted as true, an approach to religion that Epicurus and Lucretius later made systematic.
Works
- Some 70 titles are recorded, including the Little World-System; only fragments survive, c. 430–380 BCE
A common misreading
Ancient atoms are not the atoms of modern chemistry. They were posited by argument, not experiment, and were held to be strictly indivisible and without internal structure.
Influenced by
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Democritus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.