Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Anaximander

c. 610 BCE – c. 546 BCE · Miletus, Ionia · Greek and Roman

Milesian thinker who derived the cosmos from “the boundless” and wrote the first known prose work on nature.

Life

Anaximander was a younger fellow citizen of Thales of Miletus and is described in ancient sources as his pupil or associate. He is credited with drawing an early map of the inhabited world and with introducing the gnomon, a vertical rod used to mark solstices and equinoxes, to Greece.

He wrote a book in prose, of which a single sentence survives, quoted by a late commentator. It is the oldest surviving fragment of Western philosophy.

Core ideas

In more depth

The step beyond Thales. If the basic stuff is one of the familiar ones, such as water, it is hard to see how its opposite, fire, could ever have come from it. Anaximander's answer was that the source of everything must be none of the definite stuffs. He called it the apeiron, the boundless or indefinite: unlimited in extent, without beginning or end, and without the particular qualities of hot, cold, wet or dry.

The surviving sentence. One sentence, quoted by Simplicius, is the oldest surviving piece of Western philosophy. Things perish into that from which they came, “according to necessity”, for they “pay penalty and retribution to each other for their injustice according to the assessment of Time”. The usual reading is that the opposites encroach on one another, as summer on winter, and are forced to give way in turn. Nature is pictured as a lawful order in which excess is always corrected.

A world without support. Anaximander held that the earth stays where it is because it is at the centre and has no reason to move one way more than another. This is an early use of what was later called the principle of sufficient reason, and it replaces a physical prop with an argument.

Legacy. He also offered natural accounts of thunder, of the heavenly bodies and of the origin of animals, including the suggestion that humans first developed inside fish-like creatures. The details are crude, but the method is the one that lasted: explain the present world by a process from an earlier state, using only natural causes.

Why the source must be boundless. Several reasons are reported for making the origin unlimited. If it were one of the opposites, such as water or fire, it would long ago have destroyed its contrary, since each destroys the other. And if coming-to-be is never to give out, the store from which things come must be inexhaustible. The boundless also surrounds and steers all things and is called deathless and ageless, the epithets Homer gives to gods. Anaximander keeps the language of divinity and removes the personalities.

The first model of the heavens. He pictured the earth as a short cylinder, like a column drum, with people living on one flat face. Around it turn great wheels of fire enclosed in mist, each with a single opening through which the fire shows: these openings are the sun, the moon and the stars. Eclipses and the phases of the moon are the closing of the openings. The numbers he gave for the sizes of the wheels are simple multiples, which suggests that he thought of the cosmos as having a proportionate plan.

The map and the method. Later sources credit him with the first map of the inhabited world and with introducing the gnomon, the upright rod whose shadow marks the solstices and the hours. Whether or not the details are right, they fit the rest: he tried to set the whole of what is known into one picture, and where direct observation ran out he reasoned from symmetry and from what a process would have required. That combination of model and argument is the form of scientific explanation.

Works

A common misreading

His account of human origins is sometimes called a theory of evolution. He proposed that the first humans were nurtured inside fish-like creatures; there is no idea of gradual descent or selection.

Influenced by

Thales of Miletus

Influenced

Heraclitus, Parmenides

Schools and eras

Pre-Socratic

Further reading

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Anaximander in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.